Rosette re-edit

[MartinB]

In February I did a narrow band Ha OIII and SII image. It showed up a lot of nice detail but I was unhappy that despite all I did at the time I couldn't stop the Ha (green) swamping things. Have thought about it a bit since then and heres another go at it. SII - red (not much of that), OIII - blue and Ha - green. I like it a lot more now. Here are the 2 to compare. Lastest 1st

Re edit

Original

[Martin 2]

And theres me feeling proud of myself.

Very nice Martin

M2

[barkis]

And theres me feeling proud of myself.

Very nice Martin

M2

Sorry, a mistake. Ron.

[barkis]

I do admire conscientious approach some of you guys have to your imaging. You are prepared to hold work in abeyance until another time in order to get it the way you would like it to be.. More expert eyes than mine, including your own MB, will obviously see a measured improvement in the restructured image. I suppose I too would need to agree that the second attempt has made a noticeable difference, but I think it would have taken some constructive criticism from others to prompt me to make some changes. I am aware my naivety is probably showing here.

I think both efforts are excellent, the second wins by a half a length.

Ron.

[centroid]

Oooh!!, now that is nice Martin.

Very well worth the effort of the re-work.

That's the trouble with this imaging lark, we are never satisfied are we?

Its the never ending 'learning curve' I guess.

Dave

[Caz]

Bl**dy hell Martin, that's excellent. 8)

I like it a lot more now.

Don't get too excited though, will you?...

Caz

[Cloudgazer]

Lovely image Martin..

Scott

[Andrew]

Spectacular - the original was lovely but the re-edit has really brought out the detail.

[Akyra]

Worth the re-work!!! I think I can hear S@N knocking on your front door?

[CELESCOPE]

Nice job on that Martin,and well worth the time you put into it

Rog

[Cloudwatcher]

Fab!! :)

[beamish]

they're both just fantastic! but I can see why you prefer the latest.Well done Martin

Karlo

[robindurant]

WOW!!!

[MartinB]

Never ever happy! Thanks for the comments folk. Think I've played with this one enough. Need some new material now.

[dazza1639]

Stunning images Martin, the original was amazing, but the reprocess WOW.

Darren

[geppetto]

Outstanding image Martin...

Tweaked to perfection as well 8)

[MikeD]

Gotta love those narrow band images.

Great work, got to get me some OIII and SII filters A.S.A.P.

[mpeniak]

Remarkable difference there! Brilliant image :shock: