Jump to content

Nice refractor for sale ....


John

Recommended Posts

Lovely as the scope looks, I get rather angry at claims of a "research grade" achromatic refractor (12"F/12). Sorry, I do not buy that. I have seen various research instruments, and operated one (1.5m at Gornergrat, Switzerland), and the days of refractors in research are essentially gone. I have serious doubts an achromat of this size at F/12 would be really good. APM sell a 304mm apochromatic triplet at F/11.8, which suggests that get an achromatic doublet at that speed will have noticeable chromatic abberation. The APM triplet (OTA only) rather cheaper by the looks of it, leaving quite a handsome amount of money for the mount.

http://www.astroshop.eu/apm-apochromatic-refractor-ap-304-3600-cnc-ii-ota/p,8489#tab_bar_1_select

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What a load of nonsense. I can only think that the advert has been placed for one of two reasons.

1) The Vendor is delusional. I expect this is not the case. He does go a small way to justifying the price by including the following "Ed Byers states that his company will no longer be making analog setting circles. He also states that he will no longer be building any Byers Series III mountings similar to mine. He added that, if he did (which he isn’t going to do again), he would have to charge at least $400,000 for it."

or...

2) Despite the claims to the contrary, this ad is very much a look at me, look what I have (even though it was already featured in Sky & Telescope) by the item being listed at such a ridiculous price that it generates lots of forum gossip like this thread and as of this moment 2,450 views of the sale listing.

As Michael points APM offer triplets of that size (and larger) for less money. Their 12" f/7 triplet is around £160,000. And if you have a spare £500,000 give or take, you can have a binocular scope made from 2 of them as a Chinese client recent did!

post-24651-0-58607200-1371792571_thumb.j

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, there aren't many "Ed Noffsingers" on the internet... One has multiple degrees

in Psychology and Engineering Physics... Can't comment on the "sanity" aspect. ;)

A potential purchaser would either have powers of judgment or dosh to be frivolous?

Is the location Hawii or So.Ca? Flora, anyone? Throw in the house / location FREE!

I quite enjoy reading the technical specs of such things.

Guess my ST102 now needs a steering wheel! <sigh> :p

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah that'd need some kind of back yard obsy :eek::D

You mean mountaintop observatory. A white Persian cat and an underground laboratory would go nicely with it as well.

For that kind of money, get yourself a BIG dob, a big RC and a brace of fast imaging APOs or the odd Officina Stellare Veloce RH 300 300mm F/3 thrown in for good measure.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue. By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.