Jump to content

Banner.jpg.b83b14cd4142fe10848741bb2a14c66b.jpg

Sol in H⍺- 29 July 2021 - A bit of experimenting.


Hughsie

Recommended Posts

I recently purchased the Solar Astronomy book published by Axilone Astronomy and it has encouraged me to look at image acquisition and processing somewhat differently to what I have been doing so far. Admittedly there are still a lot of information to go through, however, it is a great read and well worth the investment based on what i have read through so far.

For image acquisition I use the ZWO ASI174mm camera and to date I have been adjusting exposure/gain to fill 60-70% of the histogram. Seems I have been missing a trick and with the images below I pushed this to 80% to hopefully improve SNR (in recent days I have gone further to 90%). I have also been somewhat ‘hung up’ on FPS and have kept to using Mono8 to avoid the drop off in frame rate when using Mono16 despite it offering a higher dynamic range.

Also, the combination of scope/camera pixel size and Barlow lenses suggested that with a 2.5x and 3x Barlow I would be achieving a good resolution with decent seeing, however, when using the 5x Powermate there would be significant oversampling. A few weeks back I attempted image acquisition with a 5x Powermate and adjusted the camera settings to Bin 2x2 without much success but the seeing wasn’t great either. The 29th July offered a steady sky and so not wanting to be deterred I tried Bin 2x2 again. 

Here is what was thrown out.....

Images 1 & 2 - Prominence on the North East Limb. Here Mono16 was used and I pushed the histogram to 80% which allowed me to capture both the prominences (even though they were barely visible when live on my lap top screen) and the Chromosphere. I know others have done this before but I have avoided doing this, preferring to capture the proms separately by significantly raising the camera gain. After seeing the results I am happy to change! 40% of 1,000 images stacked. Exposure time 10.7 ms, Gain = 100. Altair Astro 3x Barlow used. Bin 1x1.

06_53_40Z_Prom_NELDisc_20210729_x3_RGB.png.4681060a46727a1abf6c824b6e09bce0.png      _06_53_40Z_Prom_NELDisc_20210729_x3_Inv.png.22e03be4eefaaf87d81c23c6832ab0b5.png

 

Images 3 & 4 - Moving across to the South West Limb we have some more prominences. Again the same approach as Images 1 & 2 was adopted using the same exposure time, Gain and Barlow. I just need to sort out that bright edge of the disk.

_06_45_59Z_Prom_SWLDisc_20210729_x3_RGB.png.f5e18f8ccc69fd1d1f54bf9b17fb502f.png     06_45_59Z_Prom_SWLDisc_20210729_x3_Inv.png.e8b8fa0ff4c33c6f3591cdccbf3eef3c.png

 

Image 5 - AR12847. Mono16 used and Bin 1x1. Exposure time was 21ms with Gain set at 150. This was difficult to process and noise was difficult to control. 5x Powermate was used. 

_07_05_28Z_AR12847_20210729_x5.png.f46b029d8705b7053aa8b31aac699d36.png

 

Image 6 - Again AR12847 captured a few minutes later. Exposure time 20 ms, Gain 150. Mono16 and Bin 2x2 used. I was able to push the sharpening of the image a bit further without a significant increase in noise. The image size has also been scaled up slightly to match the size of Image 5.

_07_18_34Z_AR12847_20210729_x5B2.png.7cbc702597f959252b7747353ba0ab79.png

 

What do you think?

 

John

  • Like 12
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Very nice - I particularly like image 3.

I use Mono16 and just ignore FPS (my laptop is an old one w USB2 anyway so it wouldn't make much difference!).  I've never really looked at how much of the histogram is being filled, judging it more by eye on the laptop screen - I should probably be more systematic.

I'm most intrigued by the gain 100 - I tend to keep gain to 0 (ASI290MM) - may experiment w higher gain next time to see what difference it makes.

Wrt barlows, I did try 2.5x PM once but I found the image a bit softer than just using ROI w/o barlow - w hindsight I should have binned 2x2.

Cheers!

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue. By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.