Jump to content

Banner.jpg.b89429c566825f6ab32bcafbada449c9.jpg

tekkydave

Members
  • Posts

    1,798
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Blog Comments posted by tekkydave

  1. 2 hours ago, Gina said:

    I've considered using "Stall detection and sensorless homing" in the stepper motor instead of using endstops but it seems complicated and also not very reliable so I think I'll stick with microswitches.

    I had it working and it seemed ok. I've gone back to using conventional optical endstops as it is quieter. Plus the resume on power fail doesn't work correctly with stall detection as it sets the axis zero to the nearest 4 full steps.

    • Like 1
  2. 17 minutes ago, Gina said:

    Tried disabling CoreXY so that i could test the motors individually.  There is a problem with the RH motor (Drive 0) or X motion. The Y control moves the X carriage diagonally as expected.  That would indicate a RH motor problem yet that motor works with CoreXY mode.  I have confirmed that everything moved freely by hand.

    Shouldn't drive 0 be connected to the LH motor? Not sure it would make any difference, though. Moving either motor by hand should move the carriage diagonally. Also check the order of the wires on the connectors. I had to switch the red & blue before using motors on the Duet which were wired for RAMPS. If you were using them on Duet before then probably ok.

  3. 19 hours ago, Gina said:

    Yes, I remember that you did that Dave and if I find the bed is not held level enough I may go for your solution.  And yes, I shall be using a Duet control board.  I was originally planning on using 3 Z drive rods but with belt drive.  Decided it was too complicated and experiments with 4 rods on my Giant printer proved disastrous.  Three motors means an expensive add-on to the Duet so if I can get away with two motors I can save money.

    EDIT :- For @tekkydaveChecked cost of Duex2 - £74-34.  This seems an inordinate cost just to add two stepper drivers.  Actually, really adding only one as the second extruder driver could be used for one of the Z drives.  If only Duet had provided 6 drivers instead of 5 it would have been covered.  Considering TMC2100 drivers cost about £8, spending £74 to obtain the same result does seem excessive.  I wonder if there's an alternative.  I can see the advantage of three Z motors.  I wonder if one could connect three motor coils in series like we do for two.

    I got my Duex2 for £42.50 + vat (£51). At the time (Sept 2018) they had a special offer running.

  4. 14 hours ago, Gina said:

    Yes, I remember that you did that Dave and if I find the bed is not held level enough I may go for your solution.  And yes, I shall be using a Duet control board.  I was originally planning on using 3 Z drive rods but with belt drive.  Decided it was too complicated and experiments with 4 rods on my Giant printer proved disastrous.  Three motors means an expensive add-on to the Duet so if I can get away with two motors I can save money.

    EDIT :- For @tekkydaveChecked cost of Duex2 - £74-34.  This seems an inordinate cost just to add two stepper drivers.  Actually, really adding only one as the second extruder driver could be used for one of the Z drives.  If only Duet had provided 6 drivers instead of 5 it would have been covered.  Considering TMC2100 drivers cost about £8, spending £74 to obtain the same result does seem excessive.  I wonder if there's an alternative.  I can see the advantage of three Z motors.  I wonder if one could connect three motor coils in series like we do for two.

    It's a good point but the Duex also adds lots of extra i/o which may or may not be useful. It has onboard 12v regulator which allows me to have a mix of 24v and 12v devices without resorting to buck converters etc.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue. By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.