Jump to content

Welcome to Stargazers Lounge
Register now to gain access to all of our features. Once registered and logged in, you will be able to create topics, post replies to existing threads, give reputation to your fellow members, get your own private messenger, post status updates, manage your profile and so much more. If you already have an account, login here - otherwise create an account for free today!
Photo

What messier objects have you observed

- - - - -

  • Please log in to reply
18 replies to this topic

#1
Viking

Viking

    Proto Star

  • Advanced Members
  • 645 posts
  • Location: Cotswolds
Perhaps following on from John's thread, it would be interesting to find out what messier objects people have observed using binoculars.

Would have to know the binoculars used, and the objects observed.

Turn Left at Orion does show whether objects can be observed using binoculars.

John

#2
jgs001

jgs001

    Hyper Giant

  • Global Mods
  • 16,611 posts
  • Location: West Sussex
Good one John. Apart from the list I've posted in my thread on my bino history. There's a few other clusters and a galaxy I've spotted... My list is probably

M31, M33, M35, M36, M37, M38, M41, M42, M44, M45, M46 and M47, M50 and M52.

These were seen either with the 10x50, or 15x70's I can't remember which, but I feel a challenge coming on :(

Edited by jgs001, 24 February 2009 - 04:30 PM.

John

Celestron 80ED, Konus Vista 80s, GSO 6" RC

#3
argonaut

argonaut

    Proto Star

  • Advanced Members
  • 669 posts
My favourites are in Auriga, M36 M37 and M38.

The Messier's I have REAL trouble with are M51 and M101. I only spotted them once last year in my 15x70's. I think I caught M57, not easy. To see M57,I defocus and then refocus and just sometimes M57 will pop out at me,not quite star like.


I'm afraid my view south is not good from my backyard.

Glen.

#4
jgs001

jgs001

    Hyper Giant

  • Global Mods
  • 16,611 posts
  • Location: West Sussex
I can't believe I missed those from my list Glen, I look at them most nights :(
John

Celestron 80ED, Konus Vista 80s, GSO 6" RC

#5
argonaut

argonaut

    Proto Star

  • Advanced Members
  • 669 posts
It's the excitement of the new forum :(

Glen.

#6
jgs001

jgs001

    Hyper Giant

  • Global Mods
  • 16,611 posts
  • Location: West Sussex
:(
John

Celestron 80ED, Konus Vista 80s, GSO 6" RC

#7
Viking

Viking

    Proto Star

  • Advanced Members
  • 645 posts
  • Location: Cotswolds
From my point of view, its good to see the options/opportunities to hunt messier objects.

My list that was observed using WO 7X50s is quite modest and includes:

M42 and 45 these are easy given that they are naked eye, although the binoculars do give a richer view of the star fields. M42 not that bright when compared to a telescope/images.

M31, for me was just a fuzz ball, couldn't make out much although it did give me the star hopping direction to the nebula.

M15, was similar to M31 - at the other end of Pegasus.

Not much of a list but I might be encouraged to do a bit more using binoculars.

John

#8
Sam

Sam

    Global Moderator

  • Global Mods
  • 8,299 posts
  • Location: New Zealand
In my Bressier 10 X 50 el cheapos from Lidl:

M31, M33, M36, M37, M38, M42, M45, M52 can't remember which of the other ones I've seen through the bins.

Sam
Wairarapa in New Zealand

http://space-and-stu...paces.live.com/

#9
Andrew*

Andrew*

    Member/NGC 467

  • Global Mods
  • 7,463 posts
  • Location: Edinburgh
I've seen most of the usual suspects (OCs and bright objects) in 10x50s, and also M81/2 and M27 in 15x70s. M27 is a surprisingly pleasing bino object.

Andrew
Andrew Phethean; Edinburgh, 56° N ; 3° W.
12" f/6 David Lukehurst, ED120, Skymax 180, TS 90mm triplet, Megrez 90 and Revelation ED80 fighting it out. The loser gets fed to the lions!
Removable 110mm PST solar mod for ED120
Too many eyepieces (binoviewers is my excuse...)
HEQ5, AE Giro mount and plenty of bits and pieces...

I observe, image, sketch, deep sky, solar system - you name it...

#10
argonaut

argonaut

    Proto Star

  • Advanced Members
  • 669 posts
Andrew,

Can you split Polaris with your 15x70's? Has anyone else done this?

Glen.

#11
Apatchy

Apatchy

    Nebula

  • New Members
  • 36 posts
Since i bought the 15x70 about 9 months ago i have manged to see m3 m13 m15 m27 m29 m31 m33 m35 m36 m37 m38 m41 m42 m44 m45 m53 m57 m63 m67 m81 m82 m92.

I have only used the 25x100 once on the morning of the 20/0/09 and managed to see m3 m13 m51 m57 m65 m66 m92.
Regards Pete.


Celestron C8ngt, Skywatcher st102
Astrotrac TT320X
binoculars 10x25, 8x40, 10x50, 20x60, 15x70, 25x100
Canon 30D, 350D, 1000D, (all unmodded) + various lenses.

#12
661-pete

661-pete

    Sub Dwarf

  • Advanced Members
  • 1,803 posts
  • Location: West Sussex and trips to France
I shall make a real effort next time I'm in France to increase my 10x50 'bag'. I have a lot of time spent lounging around in a garden chair as I'm imaging, and I ought to put it to contrsuctive use (generally I'm watching for meteors)!

As far as galaxies are concerned I can definitely mark down M31, M33 and M81. M101 - I'm not sure about that one, it's quite large and diffuse making it difficult at any power. Trouble is, I know exactly 'where it is' (the two end stars of the Plough are obvious pointers forming a triangle with M101) and it's so easy to convince myself there really is a smudge of fuzz there when it may be my eyes playing tricks. M51 I'd regard as 'difficult' despite its fame as being the first-ever recognised spiral (Lord Rosse) - it's a good magnitude fainter than any of the above.

Of course, other Messiers, globs especially, are relatively easy: granted reasonably dark sky, I doubt if any glob. down to mag. 7 is beyond the reach of 10x50s. Resolving a glob. is another matter though! Perhaps I ought to do a list next time - usually I just have a quick glance at M13 and leave it at that...

I was once lucky enough to have a good look at Omega Centauri (not a Messier btw) - from a location a long way further south than France. But conditions were poor and I couldn't resolve it. On a good night from far enough south one probably can.
Pete
Orion Europa 250 & Vixen GP (kept in France); 350D (modded since April 2009)

#13
Viking

Viking

    Proto Star

  • Advanced Members
  • 645 posts
  • Location: Cotswolds
Apatchy Pete,

Quite a list. It would be interesting if you could give a brief report on the wow factor of these messier objects i.e. what can you actually see.

With 7x50 and 8x40 I appear to be a poor relation. Does this mean that I have to increase both mag and aperture?

Pete, some useful comments that give a pecking list.

A useful link might be http://www.astroleague.org/al/obsclubs/binomess/binomesa.html

John

#14
jgs001

jgs001

    Hyper Giant

  • Global Mods
  • 16,611 posts
  • Location: West Sussex
John, on the basis of the Stargazing with Bino's book, 8x40 or 7x50's are fine, at the smaller end, but fine. I'm not convinced that the 2x or 3x mag increase will really make much difference. I know in comparing my 10x50 and 12x50's that the 10x50's are my preference for several reasons, lighter, better contrast and longer eye relief. I really can't see much difference due to the change in magnification.
John

Celestron 80ED, Konus Vista 80s, GSO 6" RC

#15
Andrew*

Andrew*

    Member/NGC 467

  • Global Mods
  • 7,463 posts
  • Location: Edinburgh

Can you split Polaris with your 15x70's? Has anyone else done this?

Haven't tried TBH. Will have a go if I remember tho.
Andrew Phethean; Edinburgh, 56° N ; 3° W.
12" f/6 David Lukehurst, ED120, Skymax 180, TS 90mm triplet, Megrez 90 and Revelation ED80 fighting it out. The loser gets fed to the lions!
Removable 110mm PST solar mod for ED120
Too many eyepieces (binoviewers is my excuse...)
HEQ5, AE Giro mount and plenty of bits and pieces...

I observe, image, sketch, deep sky, solar system - you name it...

#16
Taff

Taff

    Brown Dwarf

  • Advanced Members
  • 2,273 posts
Hi John' I either use my 10x50s or 20x80s.Andromeda NGC 752' M

#17
Taff

Taff

    Brown Dwarf

  • Advanced Members
  • 2,273 posts
Hi' Please ignore i hit the wrong button.Mark:embarrassed:

#18
Taff

Taff

    Brown Dwarf

  • Advanced Members
  • 2,273 posts

Hi John with my 10x50s or 20x80s bins i have found M10,M12,M31,M13,M33,M34,M35,M36,M37,M38,M4,M42,M44,M67,M41,M52,M103,M11,
M50,M29,M27,M19,NGC869,NGC884,NGC2362,NGC752,NGC6871,NGC1981,
COLL89,IC4665,IC1396,COLL69,NGC2264,.Mark



#19
Andrew*

Andrew*

    Member/NGC 467

  • Global Mods
  • 7,463 posts
  • Location: Edinburgh

Can you split Polaris with your 15x70's? Has anyone else done this?

Had a go tonight.

http://stargazerslou...548#post1183548

And yes - M51 is tough with binos!

Andrew
Andrew Phethean; Edinburgh, 56° N ; 3° W.
12" f/6 David Lukehurst, ED120, Skymax 180, TS 90mm triplet, Megrez 90 and Revelation ED80 fighting it out. The loser gets fed to the lions!
Removable 110mm PST solar mod for ED120
Too many eyepieces (binoviewers is my excuse...)
HEQ5, AE Giro mount and plenty of bits and pieces...

I observe, image, sketch, deep sky, solar system - you name it...




0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users