I don't know which is best but I concern myself only with the practice, not the theory. I imaged with Yves' 14 nch ODK for two years and now go after similar targets with a TEC 140. The big one was working at 0.66"PP, the TEC at about 0.9.  The Barlow question is a good one but Roland Christen would not agree that the Barlow has no place. If you want to blow the standard theory out of the water have a look at this capture by Julian Shaw using a 2x AP advanced barlow at about F15 in a 6 inch