Jump to content

Stargazers Lounge Uses Cookies

Like most websites, SGL uses cookies in order to deliver a secure, personalised service, to provide social media functions and to analyse our traffic. Continued use of SGL indicates your acceptance of our cookie policy.

StarGazingSiouxsie

Celestron Focal Reducer - #94175 - Celestron say it's not compatible with Edge optics but I have found that not to be the case

Recommended Posts

Hi, 

I bought a Celestron focal reducer / corrector lens part #94175 for my non Edge CPC1100. Celestron say - in bold type no less - that this reducer is not compatible with Edge HD optics. The cost of the dedicated reducer for the Edge optics ( #94242 ) is ~ $200 more than the non Edge version 

Out of curiousity, and to make sure what Celestron say was correct, I tried the non Edge focal reducer part number #94175 on my 8" Edge telescope - and it works just fine. The field of view is expanded as it should be and the clarity to the edge of the view is as clear as when not using the reducer. IE vignetting is minimal / non existent

Has anyone else found this to be true with their Edge and non Edge telescopes? This is significant; the price difference is about $200 between the two reducers and, in my case, the non Edge reducer gives me altitude clearance on the bottom of my Evolution mount whereas using a dedicated Edge reducer ( #94242) would not. 

So if you're in a similar to me, try the non Edge reducer first before spending an extra $200.

 

Siouxsie 

 

Edited by StarGazingSiouxsie
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Interesting.

I guess they mean "not optimal" rather than "won't work at all". But you can't detect any issues? Are you using it visually only or for imaging too?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
49 minutes ago, globular said:

Interesting.

I guess they mean "not optimal" rather than "won't work at all". But you can't detect any issues? Are you using it visually only or for imaging too?

I think their, Celestron's, wording is enough to make most people think they have to purchase the more expensive reducer. I know I might sound cynical but they are there to make money. The wording from their manaul says "not compatible"

https://celestron-site-support-files.s3.amazonaws.com/support_files/94175 IM.pdf

All I can say is that I tested the non Edge focal reducer (model number 94175) in both a non Edge SCT (Cubble) and an Edge SCT (Celeste) and the viewes as far as I could tell were exactly the same. No discernable diostortion or vignetting etc in the Edge optics.

Apart from the price difference, the other significant aspectt is that the non Edge reducer is much smaller than the Edge version and this fact will be significant for people with Edge optics with single fork mounts (like me) wherein it means that I can probably use the reducer on Celeste without the optical train fouling the top of the mount where the azimuth clutch is.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

It's great you have both scopes and can try the non Edge reducer on each one and draw your own conclusion. Not cynical at all - very sensible.

I do wonder if you'd notice a difference if you were imaging rather than just visual. And in that case you'd probably use a wedge or a different mount and the size difference would be a moot point too.

However as you are visual and it's working (in fact is better due to the size difference) then that's great news for you and good to know for the future for me too if I ever feel the need / can lay my hands on one.

👍

Edited by globular
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For visual there might not be that much of a difference, but for imaging it's a different story.
Remember the old focal reducer is also a coma corrector, the EdgeHD design doesn't have coma so it will correct for something that's not there so most likely it will introduce coma or some other abberation.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By JamieHardcastle
      Hi everyone,
      My other half bought me (us) a Celestron 130 for my birthday recently.
      I have watched tutorials and done a lot of reading about collimating and various other tips since alongside several hours peering through the telescope.
      I can achieve a very crisp image of the moon which is awesome. However, trying to get a decent focus on Mars/Jupiter Saturn is proving very frustrating. The only non-blurred image of any of them is a single white-point, non dissimilar to what I can see via the naked eye. 
      i’ve tried both the 20mm & 10mm lenses and adjusted the focus in and out all the way.
       
      Any advice would be gratefully received.
      thank you, in advance.
    • By MountainDog
      I have just encountered an error message which says "NO RESPONSE 16" when I power up my 130slt. Has anyone else experienced this issue?
    • By NightSky_Wanderer
      Hi,
      I am hoping someone here may be able to offer some help or advice. I have submitted a support ticket with Celestron but I am still waiting for a reply and would really like to get this working ready for the next clear sky!
      I recently brought a starsense but have not been able to use it because it comes up with the following errors,
      Err: Model Num
      The telescope model could not be read and initialization cannot proceed.
      Critical error!
      File: ..\source\mo
      Line: 1468
      An unexpected error occurred that may cause the HC to not opperate normally.
      When updating the controller and camera it finishes succesfully but when I check for new updates it proceeds to install the same one again and again.
      I can still control the mount and I think the camera tried to do an alignment in my room.
      I have a Celestron Nexstar 6SE.
      Thanks
      Adz
    • By StarGazingSiouxsie
      Hi, 
      Just thought I'd share this in case you haven't seen it already. A recent (September 2020) article added to the Celestron 'Knowledge Base' on collimating SCTs.
      I don't claim to have seen all articles on collimation, but this is defs one of the best that I have seen. 

      https://www.celestron.com/blogs/knowledgebase/sct-edgehd-collimation-guide
       
      Siouxsie 
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.