Jump to content

Stargazers Lounge Uses Cookies

Like most websites, SGL uses cookies in order to deliver a secure, personalised service, to provide social media functions and to analyse our traffic. Continued use of SGL indicates your acceptance of our cookie policy.

Recommended Posts

Stargazers Lounge community,

The sci-fi novel I wrote takes place in a binary star system and I'm attempting to fact check before handing over to my agent. From what I gather, there are S-type, P-type & T-type systems, but I'm having a hard time wrapping my mind around the orbital possibilities. Hoping someone's expertise can help! Would it be theoretically possible to have a planet in a binary star system where there is a daily "pre-sunrise" and a "pre (or post) sunset" due to the dimmer star? And could there be daily syzygy with the stars or might it need to be less frequent? If anyone can advise or has any suggestions, it would be so appreciated! Thank you!

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Kate - an interesting (and no doubt very complex) question, for which I can't often you much I'm afraid.  A great many binaries have huge separations - many hundreds of AUs (1 AU is the Sun-Earth separation; Pluto is about 40 AU from the Sun).  Now a planet in such a system, being of relatively small mass, would orbit one of the stars rather than the common centre of mass, so I would guess the other star would be shall we say much less noticeable on the planet.

However, I imagine you are referring to close pairs with orbital periods of days or hours, so each star would come into and out of view on the planet in a complex (but predictable) way depending on many parameters.  

Many scenarios might therefore be possible, and it would be impossible to contradict them unless all the physical properties of the system were specified and your readers are all astrophysicists!  

Hope the novel does well!



Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)




Edited by Corncrake

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

If you are referring to a binary system whereby one of the stars has a planet, then i would expect that syzygy would occur quite frequently. Exactly what time scales (intervals) syzygy would occur would depend on how far the two stars are apart and, the distance of the planet from its parent star, more often in a binary where stars are closer to each other. There are sooooo many variables involved and, as mentioned above, unless the exact physical distances, masses, planes, etc are known, no one can argue against almost any scenario you choose. Regarding the pre sunrise/sunset, i imagine a planet with a tilt whereby the dimmer star just barely grazes the horizon as seen from the surface of the planet. Imagine the dimmer star never rises above the horizon and, always appears as a daily sunset/sunrise before the parent star actually rises and tracks across the sky (as our sun does). Whoa!! my mind melts, there are just too many variables, i think its safe to say that you can pretty much rest assured that no one will poke holes in your novel, unless, you are actually describing a known system who's physical properties are already understood.

I would really like to know what this novel will be titled, i would love to read it. 

Best of luck!

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By A_D05
      So I am fairly new to the hobby, what I mean is I have a Celestron Astromaster 114 right now but its hard to use because of the non computerized equatorial mount as well as the red dot sight is bad. I am mainly interested in looking at DSO’s because they seem very interesting. My question is should i get a refractor or sct for observing dso’s and sometimes planets? I want a computerized one with tracking so I don’t have to take a long time finding nebulae and galaxies. Also, is there a certain type of filter to see color on nebula when not using eaa and just viewing with your eyes? I am looking to spend between $600-900
    • By harry_tarrant
      I'm new to astronomy and have recently brought a low budget telescope (about £60). I've been out a few time to view Mars and the moon. 
      Obviously I can view the moon clearly and with great detail but when I go to view Mars all I can see is a bright circle. 
      I'm not sure if I'm being daft or what, but I can't find anywhere online that has an answer to this. 
      Details about my telescope are: 
      It's a reflector telescope 
      Model 76700
      Diam: 76mm
      Focal length: 700mm
    • By alex_stars
      Dear esteemed Stargazers,
      I would like to ask for some recommendations for an eyepiece I look for. First off, I have a 7" Mak with 2700 mm focal length. So I figure, a 12.5 (or 12.0) mm EP should be very nice to start viewing planets (my main interest) on good nights. This would result in 0.83 (0.8) mm exit pupil and 216x (225x) magnification. So far so good and I really would like to add some fixed focal length EPs to my collection as I only own 8-24 mm zoom.
      The conundrum starts with the choice of EP design and three choices I face
      shall I go old school style and buy a 12.5 mm orthoscopic EP (Takahashi or Masuyama)? or shall I  buy a more modern design with more eye relief and go for a 12 mm Vixen SLV? or do I completely miss an eyepiece and should go for that? Thus I thought I tap into the collective wisdom of the community and ask for advice.
      Clear skies,
    • By Naveen
      Hi all - looking for some
      advice on eyepieces. I have seen beautiful views of Jupiter with its moons and Saturn and of course the moon. I have two extra 32mm and 10mm plossls but am looking for better lenses for planets which will show more detail? Which ones would you suggest? Many thanks in advance!
    • By Abhinav
      Hello , I just bought my new Newtonian, reflecter and I looked jupiter and saturn the views were great but when I tried to capture thwn with my smartphone they become white balls then I adjusted the exposure settings on my smartphone everything vanishes . I got a descent photo of saturn with cassini division but jupiter was still looking like a white balls . should I buy a ZWO 120 MC or modify a logitech c270 and if you have a solution  to fix that smartphone problem please help me out .
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.