Jump to content

Stargazers Lounge Uses Cookies

Like most websites, SGL uses cookies in order to deliver a secure, personalised service, to provide social media functions and to analyse our traffic. Continued use of SGL indicates your acceptance of our cookie policy.

stargazine_ep21_banner.thumb.jpg.d744e66b98367f1c5d57b7966c303f1b.jpg

Forunke

Guiding cam randomly flips / mixes image

Recommended Posts

Ok, so this is a really annoying bug / problem that I have with my setup:

From time to time, in non regular intervals the image my guiding cam (ZWO ASI120) send seems to get flipped / mirrored or looks like it's from a completely different patch of sky.

When I'm paying attention to the guide images I can clearly see that the image seems to be flipped in some way.

It only happens for 1 frame PHD send a warning ( No star found / Star lost Mass changed) and after that everything is fine again. My gear is all connected to a single USB3 Hub which then runs via powered USB3 cable to my Pc.

I'm not binning and have the noise reduction off (though PHD might got hickups while processing) but it still happens. Sometimes there are minutes between two events sometimes it happens 5 times in a row.

It also seems like it's only happening during guiding, I haven't seen it happen during calibration yet...

 

I'm completely clueless what's happening or how to get rid of it, any help / idea is greatly appreciated.

Edited by Forunke

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I had the same flipping problem, after trying everything I could think of I stopped using it. Nothing I tried worked. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, Anthonyexmouth said:

I had the same flipping problem, after trying everything I could think of I stopped using it. Nothing I tried worked. 

So how did you go about guiding then? Another cam? Different software?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My ZWO ASI 120MM occasionally has "Split Frames" when I use it in SharpCap to take 30 second exposure sequences (frame is split vertically with left and right halves swapped)

Typically starts okay, then after a while I get a series of Split frames, then it corrects.

Never had it in PHD2, I'm not using the ASCOM driver.

Michael

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
44 minutes ago, Forunke said:

So how did you go about guiding then? Another cam? Different software?

New camera, well my asi290mc camera I usually use for planetary imaging. Spoken to a couple of others here who had the same problem. No solution found as far as I know. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, Anthonyexmouth said:

New camera, well my asi290mc camera I usually use for planetary imaging. Spoken to a couple of others here who had the same problem. No solution found as far as I know. 

Well I was thinking about getting a new guidescope... maybe I should just go for a bundle then and use the ASI120 for planetary

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Out of interest, is this the USB3 model (of the ASI120), or the old USB2 one?

James

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, michael8554 said:

My ZWO ASI 120MM occasionally has "Split Frames" 

Yes, I’ve had that too, although in my case it does sometimes happen in PHD2.  This is for an old USB2 ASI120. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, JamesF said:

Out of interest, is this the USB3 model (of the ASI120), or the old USB2 one?

James

The old usb2 one for me. Was having guiding issues from lost stars for ages and only by chance was looking at the screen when I saw it flip then flip back. During that time it lost the star. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There is a firmware "upgrade" for the USB2 models.  I found that made the camera a bit more stable at the expense of dropping the maximum frame rate slightly.  Might be worth a try?

(Actually the alternative firmware is, if I recall correctly, to return the camera to work in compliance with the USB2 specification because the default firmware bent the rules a bit , I assume to try to increase the frame rate as far as possible.)

James

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
20 minutes ago, JamesF said:

There is a firmware "upgrade" for the USB2 models.  I found that made the camera a bit more stable at the expense of dropping the maximum frame rate slightly.  Might be worth a try?

(Actually the alternative firmware is, if I recall correctly, to return the camera to work in compliance with the USB2 specification because the default firmware bent the rules a bit , I assume to try to increase the frame rate as far as possible.)

James

I'll double check mine but pretty sure I'm on the latest firmware. Sure that was one of the things I went through. Only ever use it with phd2 and brief spells with sharp cap for polar aligning. Never in sharp cap long enough to notice any issues there. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Are you running this through a usb/usb3 hub. I found mine did this but was definitely better when running it off its own dedicated usb lead to usb2 port.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Coming back to post some results from playing around with some settings.

I managed to stop the image flipping by using Subframes (PHD2, settings, camera, use subframes), which makes me think there's a bottleneck somewhere down my USB3 line.

Will have to try the suggested firmware update to see if it helps but ultimately I'll probably switch to ethernet for data transfer.

 

Thanks for all suggestions!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, Forunke said:

Coming back to post some results from playing around with some settings.

I managed to stop the image flipping by using Subframes (PHD2, settings, camera, use subframes), which makes me think there's a bottleneck somewhere down my USB3 line.

Will have to try the suggested firmware update to see if it helps but ultimately I'll probably switch to ethernet for data transfer.

 

Thanks for all suggestions!

converting to use cat5/6 ethernet wont help, any usb-cat5/6 converters will be slower than usb3. 

I did try a dedicated usb cable but still had the same issue. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I had this problem for the first time tonight.. ASI120 camera, the USB 3 ver... with ASIairPro with the ASI120 plugged into the USB3 port on the ASIair. I've been using this camera for a year now without issue. Tonight I decided to plug in a USB drive to the ASIair Pro, to capture images... After troubleshooting for an hour, I determined that using a USB drive with the ASIair caused this weird random image flip. And it's new fast USB3 stick. As soon as I took the USB stick out, everything work fine again, no more flipping images.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By khulzad
      Hi all,
      First of all mine english is not so good so sorry for that.
      I am a new to astrophotography. And my setup is
      Mount          : Skywatcher EQM 35 PRO
      Tube             : Skywatcher Explorer 150PDS (newtonian)
      Camera         : Canon 550D
      Guide scope : Svbony 60mm compact guide scope
      Guide cam    : Svbony SV105
      I know my setup is weak and cheap but for now I have them (budged problem  )
      I started the hobby at May and I took some photos that not bad for beggining. I reached 60-90 seconds without guiding.
       

      After that I thought that the time for starting improve the guiding and I bought guiding scope and cam. I know the cam is not for guiding but it was cheap, and I am planing to change it  with mono guide cam (like zwo asi120 mono) at next months.
      But my first experience for PHD2 was terrible.

      I've detected some errors and tried to fix them.
      First thing there was a unbalancing. I mounted the guide scope on the position of finder scope which is very close to edge of the main scope.

      So I fixed it (after the night I tried to guide with PHD2) and put it on the bracelet (over and middle of the main tube)
      And second thing was that there is a backlash and I tried to fix it too. I opened to gear of dec and adjusted to gear mesh.
      Except them the alignment was not so good because location was in the city (bortle scale 9) and I haven't got finder scope as you know. So I am not sure that if the stars (3 star alignment method) are correct because with nacked eye I could't see them. Next time I will do better alignment with finder for sure.
      After them I am planing to try next weekend again. But before that I need your advises to eliminate the problems which I couldn't detect or I don't how to fix them.
      For example I can not see any pulse for RA on the graph what does it mean and how can I fix it.
      And also I am not sure if there is any problem with ascom. There is no option in the drop list for EQM 35 PRO. So I choose ASCOM.SkyWatcher.Telescope and I downloaded/installed ascom driver from webpage of skywatcher.

      Thank you
      PHD2_DebugLog_2020-09-21_100115.txt PHD2_GuideLog_2020-09-21_100115.txt
    • By knobby
      Hi All, wondered if you could help me make sense of this ... new HEQ5 - belt modded by FLO, all feels good, minuscule backlash but strange guiding.
      Admittedly first time using it but baffled.
      Failed calibration see image below and guiding seemed to be Ra and Dec following each other.
      Stars look ok ish (@ 1500 mm )
      Needle galaxy is poor as only about 10 mins each in RGB
      note - it was hazy and did keep losing star in OAG
       
      Thanks for looking
      PHD2_DebugLog_2020-05-19_221608.txt
       



    • By Odiug
      Dear Avalon Enthusiasts,
       
      Do you have PHD2 Guiding Logs that you could share? Preferably at least 30 minutes long.
      I am curious about the contribution to the overall error from the individual parts of the belt reduction gear. PHD2 Log Viewer provides nice analysis capabilities for that. I am especially interested in the frequency analysis.
      Background is that I have built a motion module that uses a timing belt gear reduction quite similar to the Avalon mounts. Performance is quite good already, but I would like to compare it to the "real thing". 😃
       
      CS
      Guido
    • By Astronome
      Hello all,
      I have had a real problem with my AZ EQ6 GT:
      I have found that the MOUNT guide rate in RA is 1/3 the guide rate in DEC.  EQMOD is set to 0.9 in both axis??  This seems to have happened when I tried guiding with AA& instead of the normal PHD2?
      Is there a mount direct command to alter the RA guide rate.  Bit like the mount commands to dim the polar scope and set park position.
      You know one of these serial commands the no one ever uses??
      All the best
      John
       
    • By AstroRuz
      Hello all,
      So I routinely have issues with guiding. Last night, I was getting some solid sub exposures of 5 minutes on the Flaming Star Nebula. When it got to about 15-20minutes of the meridian, I began getting trails on my stars. Then after the flip, I was still getting trails despite PHD reporting all's well.  I moved over to the Horsehead Nebula and tried 5 minutes there, and it behaved itself. Then I tested it on the Jellyfish Nebula and it also behaved (just about - minor trails). But it just did not want to dig it with the Flaming Star Nebula, which was practically near the zenith (about 2:30am 30/11/19).
      I tried recalibrating PHD (I use Pulseguide so the scope knew where it was). I then also recalibrated PHD at Alnitak so it was near the celestial equator (as the PHD best practices recommend). I even checked my Polar Alignment (done with a Polemaster), which was fine. I couldn't find anything wrong. 
      The guide scope was slightly off alignment with the main OTA, but that wasn't making any differences before the Meridian. 
       
      I did find the helical focuser of the Starwave 50mm guide scope I was using to have some movement in it again when I manipulated the guide camera. So that's something I need to look into. But before I start throwing money at this issue, I see the terms "flexure" and "differential flexure" coming up. Can anyone shed light on what this means please?
      I tried manipulating the OTA in its tube rings, that didn't yield any movement either. The piggyback scope is secure, the g/scope is secure in its rings as well, there's no movement in the OTA focus rack and the cameras are secure in their tubes. 
      I do have my guide rings quite far back on the body of the telescope to assist with fitting the guide scope piggyback. 
      Video of g/scope play: 
       

      Flaming Star Nebula. 5 minute sub, post Meridian Flip, about 2:50am (30/11/19). Note the plate solve compass in the top left. Drift appears to be in S/W direction.

      Position of tube rings (they're now at the focus end).
      I think I am leaning towards needing to move my tube rings (once I remember to get the tools from work). 
       
       
      Equipment:
      (brand new) Skywatcher EQ6-R Pro, SW Evostar Pro 80ED, Altair 0.8x R/F, Canon 600D, Altair Starwave 50mm Guide Scope, Altair AR130 Mono Guide Cam. 
       
       
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.