Jump to content

Stargazers Lounge Uses Cookies

Like most websites, SGL uses cookies in order to deliver a secure, personalised service, to provide social media functions and to analyse our traffic. Continued use of SGL indicates your acceptance of our cookie policy.

Recommended Posts

So, I am going to take my first steps into observing and hopefully imaging the sun, and get myself a filter for the telescope, just so that I have something to do, when I am working nightshifts, or the weather is bad at night. From what I can see, all I would need is a filter like this one https://www.firstlightoptics.com/solar-filters/astrozap-baader-solar-filter.html. Is that so, or is there anything else that you would highly recommend that I get, and why? My telescope is a Skywatcher 150PDS on a Celestron AVX mount.
On the same time, I am looking at buying a baader hydrogen alpha 3mm filter for imaging. Is this also something I could use for observing, or it is solely for imaging? Just curious.

Any comments, tips, advice would be very much appreciated, as I would rather not damage either my eyes, or more importantly my equipment! ;) (jk)
 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The astrozap filter will give you 'white light' views of the sun - this means when the sun is active you'll be able to see sunspots. At the moment there's almost no white light activity as we're going through solar minimum, and things will remain quiet for the next year or two, so it's not really a great time to start. All you'd see is a big bright disc. Afraid the ha filter you've mentioned is not for solar - it's for deep sky night astronomy. You'd need to buy a dedicated solar ha scope to view the sun in ha - or a refractor with a dedicated solar ha filter - cheapest scope is the Coronado PST- but it's an expensive side to the hobby I'm afraid

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
10 minutes ago, Highburymark said:

The astrozap filter will give you 'white light' views of the sun - this means when the sun is active you'll be able to see sunspots. At the moment there's almost no white light activity as we're going through solar minimum, and things will remain quiet for the next year or two, so it's not really a great time to start. All you'd see is a big bright disc. Afraid the ha filter you've mentioned is not for solar - it's for deep sky night astronomy. You'd need to buy a dedicated solar ha scope to view the sun in ha - or a refractor with a dedicated solar ha filter - cheapest scope is the Coronado PST- but it's an expensive side to the hobby I'm afraid

Ahh right, we are literally in the middle of a solar minimum, right? How unfortunate ;) Might still buy one, just to add to my collection, and getting used to that side of it. Yeah, even a scope like that is at quite a cost, for something that isn't going to be my main occupation. 
Thanks a lot for the answer, as that helps level expectations with reality! :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Maybe I understand you wrong, but please donot use a NB H-alpha filter for solar imaging. Your eyes are far more important then your equipment!!!
For H-alpha solar imaging you need filters in the sub ångström rate like these: https://luntsolarsystems.com/product-category/hydrogen-alpha-solar-filters/
More brands are available... The Baader solar filter is ok for white light imaging with your scope, but you are thinking about a solar wedge, which gives better results, a 150 pds is not suitable, because of the heat it will produce in the tube. Better would be a smaller refractor.  

Do your homework very well before entering the endeavour of solar imaging and observing. New equipment is only a matter of money... you cannot buy new eyes... White light imaging is not very interesting at the moment, as Highburymark already mentioned. H-alpha always is always interesting.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 minutes ago, Waldemar said:

Maybe I understand you wrong, but please donot use a NB H-alpha filter for solar imaging. Your eyes are far more important then your equipment!!!
For H-alpha solar imaging you need filters in the sub ångström rate like these: https://luntsolarsystems.com/product-category/hydrogen-alpha-solar-filters/
More brands are available... The Baader solar filter is ok for white light imaging with your scope, but you are thinking about a solar wedge, which gives better results, a 150 pds is not suitable, because of the heat it will produce in the tube. Better would be a smaller refractor.  

Do your homework very well before entering the endeavour of solar imaging and observing. New equipment is only a matter of money... you cannot buy new eyes... White light imaging is not very interesting at the moment, as Highburymark already mentioned. H-alpha always is always interesting.

Of course I value my eyes a thousandfold over my equipment, hence the "joking" part! ;)
And that is why I am here, and on several other sites asking for advice, instead of just plunging into it, as I know how dangerous doing it the wrong way can be.

Is the 150 pds, not suitable, or simply not recommended for the practice? As I am hesitant of wanting to cash out for a new scope, to only observe the sun. I know that I would not be spending nearly as much time on this, as deep-sky astrophotography.

Thanks for the input! :) 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, The-MathMog said:

Is the 150 pds, not suitable, or simply not recommended for the practice

With a full aperture solar filter on the front there is no reason not to use the 150pds for white light solar visual and imaging.

I think the message was, don’t use the H Alpha filter you linking to for solar viewing or imaging as it is just for deep sky imaging. An H Alpha solar scope or Quark are the options for viewing prominences, filaments and other H Alpha features.

Also, a Herschel Wedge is another option for white light solar viewing but can only be used in a refractor, not a Newtonian. The Baader Solar Film is the best option for you, make sure you buy the visual version if you are planning on observing as well as imaging.

  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You can use the 150PDS for white light with a front filter like the Baader Solar film, but not with a wedge, because that is used on the eyepiece side, so the focused sunlight will create too much heat in the tube and burn your secondary mirror. A wedge is only used with refractors for the mentioned reason.

Solar observing is a very nice hobby and far more interesting then most people think. It is the only star we can observe from this 'close', and even in a solar minimum fase, lots of things are happening, not very visible with a white light filter, though

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As per what @Stu said above.

For a solar wedge you do need refractor. Below is my "white light" solar setup/rig. 

IMG_0675.thumb.JPG.61d0def85db3d5e798128ef6d95d020b.JPG

I do have a Thousand Oaks - Type 2 glass full aperture solar filter for my refractor. It is showing minor pin-pricks now on the metallic coatings, (it is 20 years young), and I will not use it now. All solar filters that are attached to the front of an OTA need to be checked before use, irrespective of what materials they are made from

Should you buy a refractor and a solar wedge at a later date, some brands of solar wedge do not include a ND3.0 filter.  

 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By jambouk
      I asked a few weeks ago about charging two batteries from one solar panel. I’ve now got a solar controller which can do this, see below, but I’m confused by the instruction manual, especially how I should set the “charging priority”. I assumed the unit would charge battery 1 until full, then move on and charge battery 2 until full, then go back to 1. I’m not sure what this charging priority is - image of the relevant page from the manual below. I’d be grateful to hear what you think it means.
      Thanks.
      James.


    • By MalVeauX
      Hey all,
      I made an acquisition and processing tutorial a while back (3 years ago? Yikes!) and it is fairly dated in terms of what I'm doing these days. I've been asked for a long time to make a new one showing what I'm doing these days. Specifically how I'm processing a single shot image for both the surface and prominences and how to process them together to show prominences and the surface at once. I've abandoned doing split images and composites and strictly work from one image using layers. Acquisition does not use gamma at all anymore. Nothing terribly fancy, but it's not exactly intuitive so hopefully this new video will illustrate most of the fundamentals to get you started. Instead of an hour, this time it's only 18 minutes. It's real time from start to finish. I'm sorry for the long "waiting periods" where I'm just waiting for the software to finish its routine, it lasts 1.5 minutes and 30 seconds tops typically at first. The first 4 minutes is literally just stacking & alignment in AS!3. I typically will go faster than this, but wanted to slow down enough to try to talk through what I'm doing as I do it. Hopefully you can see each action on the screen. I may have made a few mistakes or said a few incorrect things or terms, forgive me for that, this is not my day job. I really hope it helps folk get more into processing as its not difficult or intimidating when you see a simple process with only a few things that are used. The key is good data to begin with and a good exposure value. Today's data came from a 100mm F10 achromatic refractor and an ASI290MM camera with an HA filter. I used FireCapture to acquire the data with a defocused flat frame. No gamma is used. I target anywhere from 65% to 72% histogram fill. That's it! The processing is fast and simple. I have a few presets that I use, but they are all defaults in Photoshop. A lot of the numbers I use for parameters are based on image scale, so keep that in mind, experiment with your own values. The only preset I use that is not a default is my coloring scheme. I color with levels in Photoshop, and my values are Red: 1.6, Green 0.8, Blue 0.2 (these are mid-point values).
      Processing Tutorial Video (18 minutes):
      https://youtu.be/RJvJEoVS0oU
      RAW (.TIF) files available here to practice on (the same images you will see below as RAW TIFs):
      https://drive.google.com/open?id=1zjeoux7YPZpGjlRGtX6fH7CH2PhB-dzv
      Video for Acquisition, Focus, Flat Calibration and Exposure (20 minutes):
      (Please let me know if any links do not work)
      ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
      ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
      Results from today using this work flow method.
      Colored:




      B&W:




      SSM data (sampled during 1.5~2 arc-second seeing conditions):

      Equipment for today:
      100mm F10 Frac (Omni XLT 120mm F8.3 masked to 4")
      Baader Red CCD-IR Block Filter (ERF)
      PST etalon + BF10mm
      ASI290MM
      SSM (for fun, no automation)


      Very best,
       
    • By Hughsie
      I first came across the term ‘Solargraphy’ on this forum and was directed to website dedicated to the art of Solargraphy.
      This is a basic photographic method of recording the path of the Sun as the year progresses. This image commenced on 22 June 2019, the day after the Summer Solstice when the Sun was at its highest altitude in the noon day sky and finished on 22 December 2019, the Winter Solstice when the Sun is at its lowest point at noon. The silhouette of the neighbouring properties can also be made out in the picture.
      Using a basic pinhole camera I was able to record every clear day the track of the Sun across the southern sky, each day  the Sun’s altitude was getting slightly lower.
      Whilst the camera is basic, the main challenge is to avoid water damage and as you can see from the image some rain has managed to find its way inside. However, the pinhole camera is cheap to make with the following purchases made via Amazon;
      100 cable ties £5.49
      20 35mm plastic film canisters £8.88
      100 sheets of Ilford Multigrade 4 glossy photographic paper £25.98
      The remaining items were already in the house (drill bit, tinfoil, electrical and duct tape).
      Given the potential for disaster I made two pinhole camera’s and one of them provided this image, the other was washed out due to rain water getting in. Making more than one camera certainly improves the chances of success. The camera's themselves were attached with cable ties to the down pipe of the guttering and facing South.
      Anyone wishing to learn more about Solargraphy and how to construct the pinhole camera should check out Tarja Trygg's website http://www.solargraphy.com/index.php .

    • By AstroRuz
      As new condition ultra narrowband 1.25" Baader filter. 3.5nm bandpass for nice small stars.
      Bought and loved it, but using a DSLR again and have no use for this filter.
      £140, can post.







×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.