Jump to content

Stargazers Lounge Uses Cookies

Like most websites, SGL uses cookies in order to deliver a secure, personalised service, to provide social media functions and to analyse our traffic. Continued use of SGL indicates your acceptance of our cookie policy.

sgl_imaging_challenge_banner_lunar_close-ups.thumb.jpg.88a09e422111459fcea8be71befc7874.jpg

SJBob

Help with a Tal MT3S Mount Stepper Motor

Recommended Posts

Repairing a Tal MT3A Mount STEPPER MOTOR Help... 

Before anyone says "why bother" let me just answer because I'm not ready to pick up a Losmandy at the moment... 

So I have a Tal 200K which I have enjoyed quite a lot. I have always known that the single motor MT3A mount was less than ideal but it works and if nothing else, an 8" Russian made Kletsov catadioptric scope on a super solid peer mount is a pretty good conversation starter, and some of the views I've seen of Jupiter, especially with a 16mm Nagler - well they were amazing...  

So a few months ago the mount stopped tracking and slewing at a star party.   I could hear that the motor was spinning or making noise, but the mount was definitely not moving under the motor control.  I might have just waited and bought something else, but I've had some major expenses plus I'm expecting another due to a large move about to take place so I can't justify spending the money at the moment, BUT I would really like to have a working mount for the Mars opposition in July. So I decided to tear it down and take a good look.

I was able to pull the mount casing apart ... and kept going, largely thanks to the PDF AndyH so kindly shared with me that had all the great teardown photos .. despite the native German which apparently  translates into comical English with Google Translate ("Loosen the maggot whisk and the grub screws..."  is that right??? ) 

The part that took me some time was realizng after removing the screws holding the case together and removing the setting circles and springs, that it was pretty difficult to unscrew the collar holding the drive shaft in the mount casing.  For that I had to use a long screw placed into a hole in the collar as a kind of spoke to get some leverage to unscrew it.  Once it started it was easy.  Next I was more apprehensive about the drive shaft- The shaft fits through 2 bearings that had not seen freedom in 15 years, so I had to wack the shaft pretty darn hard from one end to break it free.  I did this (again thanks to the photo in the pdf) using a block of wood over the end of the sharft - hitting the wood with a small hammer, and then a larger hammer. Like the collar once it was freed up it was easy to slide it through. 

From there I just took stuff apart until I got into the drive gearbox.  The small clock-like gear assembly was not difficult to remove and finally I got a good view of the stepper motor.  At first I thought the gear was slipping on the shaft but it winds up being more serious.  I removed the gear (loosened the 2 grub screws.. or were the maggot whisks?.. ;-)  Of course I kept all the little screws in a secure place and tried to keep them attached to their mating parts when possible. But I think I'll be able to reassemble things..  

I don't see any broken gears.  My idea is to clean them up and lubricate them with a good quality lithium grease.  

THE STEPPER MOTOR
I hooked up power and the controller and  I clearly saw the drive gear is not slipping, but the motor is slipping, - internally.  So I need to either repair the motor which no longer has the torque needed to drive the mechanism, or replace it.  There's no way I can get the original motor (Tal is out of the astronomy biz and in Russia), and I don't know the specs about the motor to know how to ID it properly with an equivalent.  It may be a type NEMA 17 with 6 leads. They aren't that expensive but will it fit? (looks pretty darn similar) Will the gear fit? Does it take the same signals/control voltages?  etc.    Alternatively Can the motor be repaired?  I don't know much about stepper motors so I have non idea.. 

I know that stepper motors measure steps in degrees, and I imagine there's a spec that specifies the rate of spin, but I' don't  know how to find this out for the motor in the MT3S.  I have seen a NEMA 17 stepper motor in Amazon and it's less than $20, has 6 leads and has a 1.8 degree step.  I might just take a chance and buy the motor and see if I can figure out the wiring.. if it's the same voltage...??... 

I've attached an image of the printing on the motor and a short video showing it's unfortunate behavior.
If anyone has any suggestions how I can move forward I'd really appreciate it. 

Cheers.

Bob 

 

 

IMG_8899.JPG

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Bob,

I had an electrical driven mount with my old Tal" scope. My problems centred around the "clock drive" and not the stepper motor though. The actual size looks like, as you have rightly quoted, a Nema 17 stepper motor. Now my mount used to run from 240 volts to a transformer which supplied 12 volts A/C to the mount. Have you a transformer with your mount, if so, could you provide photos, particularly any showing data labels. Another test is to establish the rated RPM for your current motor. You could test this by hooking up the motor a gain and run it for, say 10 minutes and record how many revolutions the shaft turns. To make it easier to observe I secure a matchstick onto the shaft with a a knob of bluetack, so it mimics a single hand of a clock. Count how many revolutions it has completed after 10 minutes, divide by 10 and you have the RPM for your motor. The reason I check for 10 minutes is down to accuracy. Let us know how you fare.

Steve

  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

From what I gather the motor isn't turning, it's stuttering. The more I think about this I wonder if something has happened to the stepper driver inside the hand controller(There's a roughly 4"x2" circuit board inside). I think stepper motors need a driver for them to operate? I can remember reading about steppers and my eyes started to bleed. I think it was, to my simpleton mind, a tad too complex an explanation.

  • Haha 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Bob and welcome to SGL, the right place for advice on all things astro' related.

You may have already looked but there are a few stepper motor related vid's on Y'Tube.

Do you have a multi meter ? if so you could stab a few leads to see what voltage is being supplied to which leads when you're trying to slew, this will help with choosing a new motor if it comes to it, generally stepper motors don't go wrong very often so it may be something in the control system.

Dave

  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Greetings all and thanks for your replies.  Well the motor is kind of stuttering but without any load *maybe* it will reach the normal rpm's.  The hand controller powers the motor and has 3 speeds, solar, lunar and stellar as well as 2 slew possibilities. The video shows it trying to slew.  I can put it on the stellar setting and try to measure the RPM's over 10 minutes as Steve suggests.  I will try that.  I don't know if the stuttering will affect it but maybe I'll be able to get the RPM's for stellar rate.   Would that be enough of a specification?  I don't know much about stepper motors but from the word "stepper"I'm assuming it takes steps in a defined amount,  hence the 1.8 degree per step spec (for the NEMA17), which I would imagine corresponds to electrical pulses coming from the controller.  (or is it DC voltages on different lines?)  So if I could figure out a way to count the pulses per minute, get the frequency, maybe I can find the step angle.  The mount came with a little wall-wart transformer but it's not a multi-tap transformer.  The label says its 12V but I measured 17 and I'm a little afraid to power the mount with that.  (I accidentally burnt out one hand controller - wrong polarity - but luckily I have another..)  Normally I use a car battery charger which puts out a bit more than 12V DC .  That's always worked fine and easily powers the mount for a whole night.  So the signals that drive the motor must come from the electronics in the hand controller.  The hand controller has 6 leads that mate to the motor.  I can try measuring the voltages on each lead.  Would those be DC or pulses?  Anyone know if it matters?  I do have a multimeter but something like an oscilloscope is beyond my tool collection.  Anyhow I guess my goal is to determine the specs for this little motor and see if I can find one that matches it.   I will put a micrometer on the shaft and try to measure the distance between the mounting holes..  jeez this is some little project..  I'll try these things out tomorrow and write about it here.  I'll look for stepper motor vids on youtube -see if I can learn something..   Thanks again!!   BTW I'm repairing a roof over the weekend so it might take me a couple days to report my results.. Cheers!

Edited by SJBob
Forgot to mention...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

After having a look about the web, I found the following posts on forums regarding the MT-3S. Whilst not about fixing the std electrics on the mount, rather converting it to goto, it shows there's folks with 'hands on' knowledge of them out there. Might be worth a follow up?

http://www.iceinspace.com.au/forum/showthread.php?t=153514&highlight=Tal

http://www.astrotreff.de/topic.asp?ARCHIVE=true&TOPIC_ID=91248

 

Andy.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Roy Challen
      My Dad has asked me to sell this lovely Tal 100R on his behalf, I hope this is not against the forum rules. I owned this scope before him, and the condition is as it was when I had it. There are a few chips in the paint and some very small marks on the objective. There is a scratch on the inner surface of the dew shield which creates a horrible reflection on the objective, however this is not visible when observing. It comes with the original diagonal, mount, tripod and box, but no eyepieces. I do have some Tal plossls of a later vintage that could be added to make a complete package if desired. I fitted the SkyWatcher spreader plate/accessory tray as it was much better than the original, but does take away from its originality.
      I'm asking £200 and collection will have to be from Watford as it is a heavy item. The link at the bottom is to my first and second light reports of this scope. It sounds a little negative but that's only because the RS is that little bit better.
      If you have any questions or need additional photos, just ask.
      Cheers,
       
      Roy
       
       
    • By wookie1965
      As I am hopeless with DIY, give me a car, bike home electrics or plumbing I`m fine anything else I am rubbish. Well bought this ironing chair second hand from Ebay £9.98 came in bubble wrap on inspecting it the back is cracked and broken. For the price I am not bothered about that but could you kind people give me some ideas as to how replace it please.



    • By wookie1965
      I'm umming and arring over whether to get a solar filter or the solar wedge. I have read a couple of of things about the wedge both saying I would need a filter as well and if I buy the 1.25" I don't think it will fit in the Tal 100rs the 2 " is way out of my price range so any help much appreciated. 
    • By Stu
      A very nice quality TAL finderscope which has been nicely converted to fit a standard Skywatcher shoe (not by me!)
      Cross hair is intact, good condition generally.
      Looking for £25 Plus postage. PayPal fees paid or bank transfer please.
      Cheers,
      Stu




    • By SonnyE
      I've been whiling away my shipping wait for my hardware by watching and reading about Arduino and Stepper Motor control (Specifically). I was watching one rather informative video where the author hit on another library for the Arduino, AccelStepper.
      It appears to be a bit simpler than regular Arduino coding, which was attractive to me. But what really brought me running was that it can accelerate and decelerate on either end of the command. Think of it being a Soft Start for a stepper motor running your focuser, or a Filter Wheel. Soft Start?
      Yes, a Soft Start, and also a Soft Stop. Making your stepper motor gently begin to move, traveling to your selected point, then slowing the travel so it coasts in to what you requested. Soft Start is becoming quite common for a lot of motor driven devices.
      So my thoughts on it were to program my upcoming Arduino projects with my own Soft Start and Soft Stop to bring the focuser to Step XXX and when trying to toy in a best focus, the automatic Soft Start could aid in getting gentler adjustments.
      I bounced this idea off of my friend and he said that ramping speed was more for CNC machines and the like. And that tweaking in a focuser was more like around 70 steps to get the human eye to see the difference. I don't know (yet), but it seemed to me making any command gentler on the overall equipment might be a better idea.
      Arduino (I've been led to believe) doesn't have this Soft Start - Soft Stop in their library yet. If you would like, Here are the links to this idea:
      The Maker Show by Bret Stateham. If you scroll down on this page, there are quick links to the different parts he covers, including the AccelStepper part.
      Quick Link to the AccellStepper Part.  Or a bit before, where he refers to the Library, and where this software will be if you choose to download it for your Arduino Programming. I did, so it is there when I get my hardware here and actually begin my developing. (I prefer to have things in front of me as I prototype. I'm a hands on kinda guy.)
      I searched to see if this had been posted here, but found nothing. So I thought I'd offer it up to anyone who might be interested. OK, back to hammering on my brain. (Think: A BB in a Boxcar.)
       
×

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.