Jump to content

sgl_imaging_challenge_2021_annual.thumb.jpg.3fc34f695a81b16210333189a3162ac7.jpg

Recommended Posts

So, I have gone and got myself a Skywatcher Star Discovery 150p, which has so far proved to be a very good little scope and I've had some very good results.

I have now got the bug for imaging and have gone out and got myself a second hand Nikon D5100 and verious other equipment needed to do this, only to now find I can't get Prime Focus!!!!!!!! So the only way I can image is using a barlow x2 which obviously changes the F ratio from F5.5 to F11 slowing everything x2 this isn't to bad for planetary imaging but for DSO images not so good!!! 

After searching through lots of videos on to do this all I can find is...... 

I can either butcher the standard rack and pinion focuser that's fitted on it by cutting it down and rethreading it or by moving the primary up by 20-25mm,  which seems a shame to do a brand new scope still under warranty! 

The only other option I have come up with is changing the focuser to a Skywatcher Low Profile  Dual Speed Focuser For Newtonian Reflectors. 

Could anyone out there shed any light on this before I spend another £130 on the new focuser. 

Thanks 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Normal newtonian reflectors have this problem. The only two ways I've seen to fix this is either use a Barlow lens, or physically move your primary mirror up the tube.

I don't think the star discovery mount is good for DSO's anyway. It is an Alt-Az mount, which means that it only moves up-down, left-right. These mounts do not compensate for field rotation.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for replying Galen, the mount is a robust upgraded version of the AZ goto and I  have seen it used with great results on Dso's  using lots of short exposures say 100 x 5secs. 

This was using a CCD video camera though!!!! And the results I have had using the barlow at up to 30sec exposures haven't been too bad. 

Here's a link to where I have seen this done.. http://x-bit-astro-imaging.blogspot.co.uk/2015/08/a-ln300-video-camera-was-placed-at.html?m=

I'm also thinking of attaching a auto guided scope to help as well. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Ulysses31 said:

Thanks for replying Galen, the mount is a robust upgraded version of the AZ goto and I  have seen it used with great results on Dso's  using lots of short exposures say 100 x 5secs. 

This was using a CCD video camera though!!!! And the results I have had using the barlow at up to 30sec exposures haven't been too bad. 

Here's a link to where I have seen this done.. http://x-bit-astro-imaging.blogspot.co.uk/2015/08/a-ln300-video-camera-was-placed-at.html?m=

I'm also thinking of attaching a auto guided scope to help as well. 

Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying that you can't use it, but it's just not optimal. Normally to get results that are close to what can be achieved with an eq mount, you must put in thousands of exposures (not an over statement).

A guide scope won't really help all that much I don't think, just because the max you will be able to do without any field rotation is 20-30 seconds. And the mount should be able to track for that long unguided easily.

If I were you, don't waste your money for now. You can do some planetary and lunar, and maybe some short exposure DSO. But save your money until you have enough to get a real EQ mount. Most say that an HEQ5 is the minimum for an astrophotography, but if you really are not willing to lay down 900 pounds then an EQ5 with motors will do.

Then eventually you will save enough money for a 130pds, then you will be in business.

 

Now let me let some people who are more experienced have a turn! :) 

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

You already have your mount, yes you could butcher your focuser but my preference would be take the telescope off and fit the L bracket that came in the box and your DSLR with lens. Even if the kit lens you could get going. There is a massive thread on this The No EQ DSO Challenge. Have a look at what others are doing with a similar mount one member did use your mount with a 135mm camera lens for example and another right now with an ED80 while saving for an eq mount. Don't be put off trying have a read of that thread start at the back for the recent contributions.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 2 months later...

Hi everyone just thought I'd say thanks for all the advice.

Finally got myself up and running not the greatest effort but think it not bad for a Manchester back yard!!! 

M42

Skywatcher Star Discovery 150p AZ GOTO V4

Nikon D5100 x2 Barlow 

10x6secs exposures 

ISO 1600

Stack in DSS 

Processed in GIMP 2.8 

FB_IMG_1512135879026.jpg

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 2 months later...

hi,i am planing to modify my focuser because i dont want to use barlow anymore...but i want to be sure what i am doing.. questions are on attached picture...please help....  second pciture is with barlow...but i just feel without it thats going to be better, and adromeda will not be so wigneted...

focuser.jpg

andrm.jpg

nebula2.jpg

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 6 months later...

Hello Mislav,

Great work on this Skywatcher Telescope! I'm looking into buying one.

Do you think that prime focus is achievable without voiding the warranty using a raspberry cam, described here: ?

https://www.instructables.com/id/Raspberry-Pi-Astro-Cam/

Is the prime focus location inside the original focuser or just on top of it?

Kind regards,

Jean-Luc

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 30/08/2018 at 01:21, Jean-Luc74 said:

Hello Mislav,

Great work on this Skywatcher Telescope! I'm looking into buying one.

Do you think that prime focus is achievable without voiding the warranty using a raspberry cam, described here: ?

https://www.instructables.com/id/Raspberry-Pi-Astro-Cam/ 

Is the prime focus location inside the original focuser or just on top of it?

Kind regards,

Jean-Luc

 

Prime focus is generally located well above the most inward travel position of a focuser to allow various eyepieces to come to focus.  The problem for the OP was that it wasn't at least 55mm, the required distance for a T-mounted DSLR.  That Raspberry Pi imager should have no problems coming to focus in that scope (or any other for that matter).

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 3 months later...

I think that this telescope would be very good for beginners, especially for teenagers thanks to the new wifi goto system manageable on smartphones. It's a shame that it cannot reach prime focus with a dslr. 

I was thinking there should be no problem with recent mirrorless camera, because Sony or Fuji mounts have a flange focal distance of 16, 17 mm insted of 44, 46 like Dslr...

...Unfortunately it seems all T mounts for  Fuji and Sony are made to bring that distance to 55 like in Dslr!

Having a fuji xt-20 I am curious to know  if someone made it, either by cutting the adapter or finding a short adapter because I am thinking to buy this telescope to use it in camping with my children 

Link to post
Share on other sites

I didn't find anything ready made. I am scared it would cost more than 50$.

Looking at the measurables given in the video above, I think one could buy a Sony or Fuji T adapter (15$) then unscrew the T ring (6 mm), cut away almost all the tube and keep just the flange (7-8mm), glue the flange to the T ring. The piece should be short enough to go directly on the scope eyepiece holder which is free to rotate, so non need to have a rotating T ring.

The resulting adapter would be long as a standard Canon T adapter but the sensor is only 16-18 mm deep instead of 44 as in Canon Eos. That's a few mm more than the 1 inch required to achieve prime focus according to the very clear video fron Nige.

Wondering if someone tried. And if someone sells fuji mount flanges, just the flange.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I think I found it for sale. It's the same piece hand made in the video of Nigel G but for Fuji mirrorless, and technical specs says that it adds only 10mm to the camera flange focal distance which is 17.7

I guess we are quite inside the focal range, nevertheless I will try to check on the OTA before buying it.

I must say that italian Sky Watcher client service was wonderful. They gave me hints and found me the piece itself.

That basically would mean that all new mirrorless camera can achive prime focus on this tube

6533_2.jpg

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 1 month later...

The exposure time will vary by the direction the telescope is pointing and the altitude. The range might be anything from 10 seconds to 45 seconds. East or West 0-60 degrees altitude are the best directions and altitude range to point.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 3 months later...
On 05/12/2018 at 12:47, Matnb said:

I think I found it for sale. It's the same piece hand made in the video of Nigel G but for Fuji mirrorless, and technical specs says that it adds only 10mm to the camera flange focal distance which is 17.7

I guess we are quite inside the focal range, nevertheless I will try to check on the OTA before buying it.

I must say that italian Sky Watcher client service was wonderful. They gave me hints and found me the piece itself.

That basically would mean that all new mirrorless camera can achive prime focus on this tube

Hi guys, first time posting here. My apologies if I was supposed to introduce myself as a new member, but as I didn't see that requirement I decided not to.

Anyway, I am also an owner of SD 150p, aforementioned telescope, and as well have an urge to take a few pictures. As I don't want to have a laptop with me, or own one just so I could take a picture of the night sky, I was looking into getting a "standalone" camera. 

You guys got my attention with mirrorless camera, which could possibly get into prime focus on this telescope. If I was to buy for example Canon M100, which part would I need to buy to be able to attach it to my telescope in prime focucs?

Matnb, you said you found an attachment for sale, do you have a link for it maybe?

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

I have an SW Explorer 150P and had similar issues with my Sony a350- couldnt achieve prime focus with a T ring inserting the tube into the draw tube on the focuser.

I then found that if I unscrewed the nose piece off the T ring and did likewise with the focuser- unscrew the draw tube (if that is what the bit you insert the eyepiece into is called), I could screw what was left of the 1 1/4 EP adapter to the T ring and bingo- prime focus achieved.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah I guess my telescope has different kind of threading because people say we need that "nose" part of the adapter. Not sure why there isn't an adapter for that type of threading ? Correct me if I'm wrong

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 5 months later...
On 02/05/2019 at 11:56, Grahlom said:

Yeah I guess my telescope has different kind of threading because people say we need that "nose" part of the adapter. Not sure why there isn't an adapter for that type of threading ? Correct me if I'm wrong

 

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By KevinPSJ
      What a great night last night. Found my first Virgo cluster galaxies!
      Located without seeing anything in my finderscope - figured I must be in the right place as there were almost no stars. Had to take a quick shot at high ISO to confirm there were galaxies there. Really pleased to see 3 Messier galaxies and a whole bunch more pop out after 20 min. If I hadn't spent a hour messing about with polar alignment and collimation I would have grabbed more integration time. Oh well - lesson learned.
      While this was imaging I got out my binoculars and found M104 too. Will try to image if there's another good night like last night.
    • By wavydavy
      For sale 450D camera modified for astronomy, the IR filter has been removed to allow the important red emission nebula to come through. The price is £140.
      This camera has a very low shutter count of 1588, in very good condition, comes with 1 battery and charger (connects via USB to computer or smart phone socket ect ), I don't have the original box, but will pack, very well. The price includes special delivery. This is for the camera body, no lens. Any questions please email me any questions......clear skys.




    • By luvalezim
      Hello.
      My name is Luiza, I am a student of Computer Engineering in São Paulo, Brazil and I would like to ask for your help.
      As yesterday was the super pink moon day, I, at about 22:50, decided to take several photos of the moon using my phone and my non-digital telescope. And, analyzing the photos now, I realized that in some of them there are certain objects that I can't say exactly what they are. Could you help me identify them, please? I am not sure if they are satellites, ISS, Hubble, etc ... and I am very intrigued by themphotos.rar.
      P.S: the objects are in the lower left corner of the images






    • By StarPrincess
      Moon Surface with AstroDinsk
      23 April 2021 21:35
      Celestron Nexstar 6SE
      ZWO ASI astrocamera 462mc
       
    • By blameTECHIE
      I don't expect any replies - think I'm just braindumping for the mental wellbeing aspect of a frustrating night.
      ---
      Having been ill through the week, Saturday found me feeling well enough to get outside and see if I could hook some things together and try to get FirstLight through some of my recent purchases.  I've been using my Star Adventurer mini-rig [SA non-wifi, Canon 200D (unmodified), >30yr old Tamron 200mm f3.5] but knew things were going to be very different, and was keen to get going.
      So the kit was all lined up:
      > Laptop (Win10), Raspberry Pi4 with Astroberry
      > EQ6-R Pro
      > SW 80ED-DS Pro (Kit), SVBony SV106 190mm/50mm Guide Scope
      > ZWO ASI 224MC, Canon 200D, SVBony SV205, 7TC ASI 120MC clone
      > USB GPS Dongle (G72 G-Mouse Glonass Beidou GNSS) for location
      and mains power for all via various PSUs with enough USB cables to circle the planet
      ---
      Didn't take too long to get both Win10 (ASCOM) or Astroberry (INDI) talking to the mount and progress was being made - RA/DEC all seemed fine so onto the cameras.  Found a distant object and SharpCap gave me images for all three USB devices once I had the SVBony as a Windows WebCam (RESULT!) and the same through INDI on the Astroberry, all three displayed images when enabling Streaming.
      Settled on EQ6-R, SW 80ED, ASI224MC for imaging, SV106/SV205 for guiding
      That's it (I thought!) and I broke down the rig and moved it to the lawn - I say lawn, more like a mossy bank but serves the purpose - and wait until dusk where a simple Polar Align and I'll be grabbing images of M51 Whirlpool in no time ...............

      (I must cut the lawn, even if just to get rid of the blue from spray-painting a new table a couple of weekends ago)

      (please ignore the middle dew heater, was there to remind me to put it on the guide scope later)
      ---
      PA on the Star Adventurer, 30mins (5mins for the alignment, 5mins for remembering which phone app has a PA Clock and the obligatory 20mins to find the flamin' polar illuminator!) - this has been giving me consistent 5min exposures with no trailing.
      PA on the EQ6-R is 'interesting' - I have a QHY PoleMaster but am waiting on the adapter from FLO (stock issues) so it was SharpCap alignment.
      Wait for it to get dark enough, then get focus, then wait for platesolving in a "change exposure, gain, star threshold, black threshold, platesolve again" loop for over an hour.  Woohoo, plate solved ..... oh, rotate around RA ..... and perform the same operation again ..... ARGHHH!
      Over two hours later (probably more like 3hrs+) I've got polar alignment to within 12 seconds (wishing I'd screengrabbed that now).  I really don't like the adjustment mechanism, the thread pitch is far too high for minute adjustments of alignment!
      ---
      And onto guiding ........................ or maybe not.
      PHD2, Nothing through it at all .... then remembered I'd not refocused the guide scope, then it was taking the Darks library.  Still nothing.  Opened the SV205 via SharpCap and got focus, switched back to PHD2, still nothing ...... hmm, is this just an unsupported camera (windows 'webcam').  So switched out for the 120MC copy - Amazon 7TC special.
      Repeated the SharpCap for focus, then PHD2 Darks library and BOOM I have stars showing up in PHD2 - RESULT ...... I'll leave it at that for a moment and try looking at something, see what I get from the 224MC main camera and what PHD2 gives me in the guide scope.
      So onto the next 'learning opportunity' - target selection
      ---
      Erm, how do I select a target for goto with just two camera apps .... aha, Stellarium
      No Telescope selected, easy - it went something like this:
      "Open Stellarium, select telescope, select ASCOM ... there we go ... nope, it won't connect ... restart everything (twice) ... redo settings (twice) ... check ASCOM diagnostics (all passed) ... quick google search, aha I'm not the only one, you have to select the scope within the options pane ... what options pane .... oh, scroll down ..."
      And I now have Stellarium control of the scope - again a RESULT - it's taking time but I think I'm making progress here .... hmm, it's getting bloody cold, wow, it's midnight!
      ---
      So I now have an in focus 224MC, an in focus guide scope and control over the mount, here we go ... I'll be stacking images in the morning and making millions from selling prints online
      NOPE!
      Easy targets for testing were below the horizon (basically M42) so I'll just pick Vega and make sure slewing works, imaging works and can see how guiding works.
      Nothing, no bright star at all - okay, bigger target - the moon.
      Again nothing, no bright screen - so switched out the camera for a 26mm LER EP and a diagonal and manually aligned the moon - then, and here comes stupid, refocused (!) for the moon.
      ---
      Stellarium wasn't syncing with the mount - I was 'off' on any selected target and by a lot
      Quick google search and I'm no the only one - no sync points on my clean build so wasn't that, but use of the GPS dongle for location and TIME might be the problem.
      ---
      And at this point it as 2:30am - prime viewing time last night with the moon disappearing in the West behind me - the garden slopes due-West to due-East so I only get Partial-North>East>Partial-South viewing.
      Time to give up, have a small glass of Red and look for more things to buy on SGL/Astro B&S.
      ---
      Today - well I had to break everything down to get it into the garage (too heavy to carry as one with current health) - I'll try to get the ASCOM/GPS element sorted out and maybe this evening try some targeting/lunar rate tracking so see if that major element is resolved.
      And, if you've made it this far, please accept this for your perseverance🎖️, you've earned it.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue. By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.