Jump to content

Stargazers Lounge Uses Cookies

Like most websites, SGL uses cookies in order to deliver a secure, personalised service, to provide social media functions and to analyse our traffic. Continued use of SGL indicates your acceptance of our cookie policy.

astrocatinfo

Filters: Baader or Astrodon? LRGB and NB

Recommended Posts

Good morning,

I'm close to purchase the ASI1600 with the filter wheel and OAG. I have a couple of questions about the filters:

 

Is it worth to go for the Baader LRGB? Or can I go for the ZWO ones (maybe are Optlong?). Some bad reports on the L filter on the later.

For narrow band I was thinking on the Astrodons: 5nm Halpha, 3nm OIII and SII. I don't want to go for the 3nm Halpha and the same NII... not high polluted area, less filters. Am I right? Always looking for a balance price-caracteristics.

 

About the size, 31mm unmounted.

 

Thanks so much for your help,

 

Aleix

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you want to save money and you don't have much LP then 5nm [OIII] and [SII]. get a 3nm HII for now and add a [NII] later. If you buy a 5nm HII and then decide you *would* like to try [NII] as well, you'd have to get a 3nm HII after all.

Of course, if you have no intention of ever exploring [NII], and your LP isn't bad then 5nm for all filters makes sense (At least to me).

Just a thought, 3nm [OIII] would be a bit more resistant to moonlight, which is LP to an astrophotographer.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, DaveS said:

If you want to save money and you don't have much LP then 5nm [OIII] and [SII]. get a 3nm HII for now and add a [NII] later. If you buy a 5nm HII and then decide you *would* like to try [NII] as well, you'd have to get a 3nm HII after all.

Of course, if you have no intention of ever exploring [NII], and your LP isn't bad then 5nm for all filters makes sense (At least to me).

Just a thought, 3nm [OIII] would be a bit more resistant to moonlight, which is LP to an astrophotographer.

That's why I was considering 3nm OIII. Because of the moon effects... is it the same with SII? Worth going to 3nm?

How good or bad would be to stay only with Halpha 3nm? Which deep sky objects have important signal in the NII band?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The further towards the blue the worse the moon will affect your images, so H N & S will be less affected.

As for suitable targets for N part of the fun is looking for them. The Rosette is s good target as is M27 and possibly other planetary nebulae. Might be worth looking at other pure emission nebulae.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not sure that I'd use an OIII in the moon. I've never found them terribly moon proof. I have both the Baader 7nm and the Astrodon 3 in Ha. The Astrodon is vastly more moon proof and gives tiny stars, which is great either for combining with LRGB, where they don't affect the star colour, or for standalone narrowband images where tiny stars are just nice of themselves. I've never tried the AD 5 Ha which admits the N11 line. We went for the 3 because of its higher contrast which is good for adding to natural colour images.

If I shoot Baader 7nm in the TEC 140 at 1015mm FL the detail is comparable with that of the 3nm AD shot in the Tak 106 at 530mm. In any other comparison the Tec massively out resolves the Taks, so the Astrodon is in another league. It is also incredibly easy to process.

Olly

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I started with Astrodon 5nm Ha, 3nm OIII and 5nm SII.  More recently I've bought 3nm Ha and found it much better for tighter stars and keeping a full moon at bay :)  To match I bought the 3nm SII (already having 3nm OIII).  Now it seems I could do with NII.

Fortunately, the ASI1600MM-Cool works fine with the cheapest Astrodon size of 1.25" mounted filters and the ZWO EFW mini with negligible vignetting.  But the diminishing value of the pound has forced the price up to nearly half a grand :(  I think I should have bought the 3nm NII filter instead of the SII.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Agree with Olly that [OIII] isn't very moon-proof, but up here we have to take any clear night on offer, and sometimes that might mean getting [OIII] data with some moon (No more than half moon, and 90deg or so away), so the narrower the bandwidth the better.

Regarding [SII] vs [NII] I've found [NII] to be more use, often with a stronger signal. But that's just my personal experience, YMMV as they say.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just for the fun of it here is an image of M42 from a couple of years ago in the "forbidden" lines of [SII], [NII], and [OIII], mapping sulphur to red, nitrogen to green and oxygen to blue, I think there was an hour of each in 10 min subs. To reiterate, there's no hydrogen in this image.

In my defence, and because I know it's a pretty poor image, I *was* still learning the art and craft of NB imaging.

Forbidden M42.jpg

If we ever get another clear night this winter I may revisit M42 (Visiting it with fire and sword :evil4:)

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I can see I'll have to get an NII filter and hope for some time to use it :D  Watch out for some of my lesser used kit in the sales section after Chrimbo :D

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As I've been researching not yet in the market for 31mm. I hope they realesed it soon together with the NII SII OIII...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The 3nm are good to be sure, however..signal can be very very weak, I've run 20 x 20 mins on a target recently without much to show for it, be prepared to take long and lots of subs.

Ray

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Anthony RS
      Hello,
      I'm selling these 2 filters since I'm getting a mono astro cam. The filters are barely used and in perfect condition, no scratches, no fingerprints, not even dust. They are both amazing filters, probably the best investment I've made. I've attached some images
      taken with these filters, using a 100$ celestron newtonian, a 250$ Canon 500D and the infamous AVX. Also attached are images of the filters showing their perfect condition.
      Astronomik CLS-CCD Canon Clip in Filter: https://www.astronomik.com/en/filter-gegen-lichtverschmtzung-filters-against-lightpollution-lpr/cls-ccd-filter/clip-filter-eos-mit-astronomik-cls-ccd.html
      Original price including VAT is 155 Euros (around USD 182). I got it for around USD230 including VAT, shipping and custom taxes.
      Selling for USD 120.
      Astronomik Ha 12nm Canon Clip in Filter: https://www.astronomik.com/en/clip-filter/clip-filter-canon-aps-c/clip-filter-eos-mit-astronomik-h-alpha-ccd-12nm.html
      Original price including VAT 194 Euros (around USD 228). Got it for around USD 270 including VAT, shipping and custom taxes.
      Selling for USD 180
      I am willing to ship them on my own expense using LibanPost (from Lebanon). Shipping might take time; if you would like to use some other shipment method please contact me to discuss the price. 
      Feel free to buy one or both together.
      Let me know if you have any questions. 
      You can also contact me on <private email address removed>
      Cheers,
      Anthony









    • By endlessky
      I have been waiting for this telescope for almost five months. Since May, 19th, to be precise. The day I went to the TS Italia store and saw for the first time the SLD model, model now discontinued. I even missed the last available piece just for a few days, once I finally placed my order, June, 25th. It was to be replaced by a newer model, available at the end of the Summer.
      Boy, am I glad I did miss it. The wait was definitely worth it. The new and improved model is simply beautiful. I fell in love with it as soon as I saw it on the Tecnosky website a few weeks ago, when they posted the product sheet. But in person, it's even more beautiful.
      So, the people from the store emailed me Friday, October the 2nd, telling me that it was finally available for pickup. I read the message only a whole hour later and it was soon going to be closing time. I started calling at 4:30 PM and I finally managed to get my phone call through at around 5:05 PM. The store closes at 6:00 PM and doesn't reopen until Monday. And it's 40 minutes away from where I live. I made it there in 35. There was no way I was going to have to wait till Monday, knowing my scope was only a few minutes away.
      So, here's the pre-unboxing picture:

      - top left, brown box, behind: Vixen clamp for guide-scope
      - top right, white box: 60mm f/4 guide-scope
      - top left, white boxes: T2 Nikon ring, 30mm spacer, adjustable spacer
      - center, behind white boxes: Optolong L-Pro 2" filter
      - right of filter: spacers mounted and already calibrated for 55mm backfocus, for eventual use of the ZWO ASI 224MC camera with the refractor
      - top right, Bahtinov mask
      - underneath the white boxes, top left: Losmandy bar to attach telescope to my NEQ6 Losmandy saddle
      - big box underneath all of the above: Tecnosky 80mm f/6 FPL-53 OWL Triplet, with carrying case and 0.8x 4 elements flattener/reducer
      - ZWO black case: ZWO ASI 224MC guide-camera / planetary camera
      - front left: Talisker 57° North and two glasses (don't mind the shape of the glasses, they are the closest to Whisky suitable glasses that I currently own...) ready for me and my wife to celebrate the end of the wait
      - front right: box for the aforementioned Whisky
      I actually waited for yesterday (Saturday, the 3rd) for the unboxing, because I wanted my best friend Omar to be present and help me with filming and taking pictures. We have been friends since we went to kindergarten and we always have had astronomy as a common interest.
      It just so happens, to my immense surprise, that my telescope is actually SN. 0001, so I own the first telescope ever produced of this new series. The certificate is also very promising, with a Strehl ratio of 0.974 and a Ronchi test that seems very well behaved. I like a little less the red edges on the lenses, but I guess only time and a proper visual - and astrophotographic - session will be able to tell.



      Obviously the "new equipment curse" didn't help, but we got almost a whole hour with clear sky patches and obviously I couldn't pass up the opportunity. I quickly setup with the bare minimum necessities for a visual observation and me, my wife and my best friend Omar - who helped with the staging, recording and directing of the unboxing event - took a quick look at the Moon, Saturn, Mars, M31 and Perseus Double Cluster.
      I can definitely understand now, even if the seeing wasn't perfect, and my eyepieces didn't offer enough magnification (25mm and 10mm give me 80x and 200x, with my C8, but with a native focal length of 480mm, even with a Barlow 2x, we could only achieve about 38x and 96x, respectively), what people mean when they say that an apochromatic refractor brings out the objects from the background sky. The contrast was stunning, the stars were absolute points, pinpoint, small and sharp (with my C8 they always have kind of a "blob" feeling), the contrast on the Moon was fantastic and I could see many details, despite it being almost full, and only at 48-96x. I think it passed the visual test with honors. I was also very happy to be able to see the Double Cluster all in the same field of view for the first time. Saturn was well defined, could clearly make out the rings - don't recall, in all the excitement, rush and cycling between me, my wife and my friend, if I saw the Cassini division, but I'll definitely try again next clear sky night. Mars was also beautiful, could clearly see its rusty red color, the polar cap and some darker, black features on the surface.
      I really can say it's a beautiful telescope, very well made and machined. The attention to details is really of another level, the paint finish is very nice and matte. Also very lovely all the different red and black anodized surfaces, they really give it a nice finish and personality. The focuser is also the best I have ever had on a telescope. Very smooth, precise, with no backlash. Coming from a C8 where every touch of the focuser throws off the image all over the place and the backlash is quite significant, I really appreciated how easy it was to fine tune focusing with a proper focuser, especially with the 10:1 focusing knob.
      I can't wait to be able to take the first pictures of some star field, to check if even photographically the telescope lives up to my expectations. I hope to get pinpoint stars corner to corner and that the backfocus won't be something too hard to make perfect.
      Here's some accessories.

      Optolong L-Pro 2" filter, Bahtinov mask, Losmandy dovetail to replace the Vixen one the telescope comes with, Nikon T2 ring and spacers to use the ASI 224MC with the correct backfocus directly on the telescope, instead of a guide-camera.
      Here's the 60mm f/4 guide-scome, with Vixen clamp.

      And the ZWO ASI 224MC guide-camera.

      Here's the mandatory celebration beer, at Corte dell'Orso (the Bear's Courtyard).
      It's a Belgian sour beer, lambic style. Oudbeitje by Hanssens Artisanaal, with added strawberries. A very nice beer, sour, tart and fruity. Could definitely taste the strawberries.
      Cheers!

      Here's a couple of pictures of the full setup, with everything mounted on my Sky-Watcher NEQ6 Pro.
      The setup is in its astrophotographic configuration: mount, telescope, guide-scope, guide-camera, filter, flattener/reducer and at the end the Nikon D5300 astromodified. All controlled by Astroberry on my Raspberry Pi 4 4GB, conveniently mounted on a bar across the two telescope rings.


      And finally a close up of the rig.

    • By yltansg
      Hi,
      I would like to share with you an article written by me on high-resolution solar imaging in different wavelengths.  Glad that the European Physics Journal (EPJ) Web of Conferences published it. You can read it at:   

      https://www.epj-conferences.org/articles/epjconf/abs/2020/16/epjconf_seaan2020_01002/epjconf_seaan2020_01002.html
      You can see the different layers of the Sun in high-resolution images using different setups.  
       
      Best regards.
      Alfred 
    • By Horizon_Brave
      So...a question...let's say you want to shoot in a slightly light polluted area...but you also want to use the IR/UV cut filter...how can you use both then? You can only apply one filter at a time...so are is this a sort of 'pick your poison'? So you can't have IR/UV filtered along with Light pollution as well?
      For example here:
      https://expertphotography.com/best-astrophotography-filters/
       
      There's a ton of great filters...but how is it possible if you need a light pollution filter because of the area you're in..but you also want to cut IR/UV ? It seems like you can only do one at a time.
       
       
      Thanks all..
    • By inFINNity Deck
      As I have replaced them with new-style versions, I have two old-style ZWO 36mm unmounted narrowband filters for sale:
      - H-alpha
      - S-II
      They are pre-2018, so with both sides silver instead of yellow&purple, and come in the original, but opened, packaging. Condition like new.
      Attached images have been made with them. Any decent price will do.
      Nicolàs
       



×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.