Jump to content

2052839955_Mobilephonebanner.jpg.a502a319d7033354d442937f2edd0c2c.jpg

Search the Community

Showing results for tags 'effective focal length'.

  • Search By Tags

    Type tags separated by commas.
  • Search By Author

Content Type


Forums

  • Welcome
    • Welcome
  • Beginners
    • Getting Started General Help and Advice
    • Getting Started Equipment Help and Advice
    • Getting Started With Observing
    • Getting Started With Imaging
  • Community
    • Official SGL Announcements and Events
    • StarGaZine
    • SGL Challenges and Competitions
    • SGL Star Parties
    • Star Parties & Astro Events
    • Celestial Events Heads Up
    • The Astro Lounge
  • Retailers
    • Sponsor Announcements and Offers
    • FLO Clearance Offers
    • IKI Observatory
    • Supplier Reviews
  • Equipment
    • Discussions - Scopes / Whole setups
    • Discussions - Binoculars
    • Discussions - Mounts
    • Discussions - Eyepieces
    • Discussions - Cameras
    • Discussions - EEVA Equipment
    • Discussions - Software
    • DIY Astronomer
    • DIY Observatories
    • Member Equipment Reviews
  • Observing
    • Observing - Discussion
    • Observing - Reports
    • Observing - Solar
    • Observing - Lunar
    • Observing - Planetary
    • Observing - Deep Sky
    • Observing - Widefield, Special Events and Comets
    • Observing - with Binoculars
    • Observing and Imaging Double and Variable Stars
    • Sketching
  • EEVA (Electronically Enhanced Visual Astronomy)
    • EEVA - Discussion
    • EEVA - Reports
  • Imaging
    • Imaging - Discussion
    • Imaging - Tips, Tricks and Techniques
    • Imaging - Image Processing, Help and Techniques
    • Imaging - Smartphone / Tablets
    • Imaging - Lunar
    • Imaging - Solar
    • Imaging - Planetary
    • Imaging - Deep Sky
    • Imaging - Widefield, Special Events and Comets
    • Imaging - Showcase Threads
  • Science
    • History of Astronomy
    • Physics, Space Science and Theories
    • Radio Astronomy and Spectroscopy
  • WADAS's WADAS Discussion Forum
  • Beaufort Club's Topics
  • Swindon Stargazers Club's Topics
  • East Midlands Stargazers''s Topics
  • Central Scotland Astro's Topics
  • SGL Cumbrian Skies's Topics
  • Herts, Beds and Bucks Group's Topics
  • SGL East Anglian Group's Topics
  • South Leicester Observers's Topics
  • South Wales Group's Topics
  • SGL Surrey Observers's Topics
  • South Yorkshire Stargazers's Topics
  • Yorkshire Astronomers's Topics
  • Devon and Cornwall's Topics
  • West Midlands's Topics
  • Essex Cloud Dodgers's Topics
  • Essex Cloud Dodgers's New equipment
  • NLO and Planetarium's Topics
  • Astronomical Society of Edinburgh's Discussion
  • Dorset Stargazers's Topics
  • Hairy Stars Club (Comets)'s Tutorials and Guides
  • Hairy Stars Club (Comets)'s General Discussion
  • Hairy Stars Club (Comets)'s Observing Campaigns
  • Hairy Stars Club (Comets)'s Analysis results
  • Hairy Stars Club (Comets)'s Useful Links
  • Pixinsight Users Club's Pixinsight Discussion Forum
  • Club Europe's Club Europe Astro Chat

Calendars

  • Astro TV
  • Celestial Events
  • SGL Calendar
  • Astro Society Events
  • Star Parties
  • WADAS's Events
  • Beaufort Club's Events
  • Astronomical Society of Edinburgh's Events
  • Dorset Stargazers's Events

Blogs

  • Blog 16571
  • Blog 21603
  • Blog 26813
  • Blog 29136
  • peaceonyou's Blog
  • Blog 12649
  • Blog 16572
  • Telescope Project
  • Blog 26817
  • Blog 29137
  • Viewing the night sky through a Telescope
  • 2019/20 Challenge
  • Blog 12650
  • Blog 16575
  • Blog 21680
  • Blog 26819
  • Blog 29139
  • perks2008's Blog
  • AstroHeart UK
  • Blog 12652
  • Blog 16579
  • Blog 21702
  • Blog 26834
  • Blog 29156
  • Workshop Tinkering
  • Blog 12654
  • Blog 16597
  • Blog 21731
  • Blog 26845
  • Blog 29168
  • My Astronomy Life
  • Blog 12658
  • Blog 16609
  • Blog 21740
  • Blog 26846
  • Blog 29177
  • 2019 Observations
  • Blog 12663
  • Blog 16670
  • Blog 21790
  • Blog 26848
  • Blog 29180
  • papak's Blog
  • Astrophotography is hard.
  • Blog 12664
  • Blog 16672
  • Blog 21791
  • Blog 26850
  • Blog 29192
  • CptManering's Blog
  • Star Gazing Travels
  • Blog 12665
  • Blog 16698
  • Blog 21832
  • Blog 26857
  • Blog 29204
  • blackout's Blog
  • DIY stepper focuser
  • Blog 12668
  • Blog 16717
  • Blog 21884
  • Blog 26907
  • Blog 29209
  • Naemeth's Blog
  • New secondary mount for old Fullerscope
  • Blog 12673
  • Blog 16718
  • Blog 21939
  • Blog 26909
  • Blog 29211
  • TransparentBadger's Blog
  • SOUTH WEST ASTRONONOMY FAIR 2020
  • Blog 12674
  • Blog 16724
  • Domain backordering & monitoring service
  • Blog 26917
  • Blog 29215
  • M00NMonkey's Blog
  • How the buy stop order works
  • Blog 16725
  • Blog 21987
  • Blog 26927
  • Blog 29219
  • dobsonuser's Blog
  • Observation Log
  • Blog 12688
  • Blog 16729
  • Blog 22037
  • Blog 26930
  • Blog 29220
  • Tibbz's Blog
  • Astro-related Auction 'Lots'!
  • Blog 12692
  • Blog 16742
  • Blog 22067
  • Blog 26946
  • Blog 29225
  • Alfven's Blog
  • Celestron C8, C6, Explore Scientific 127 ED Triplet
  • Blog 12695
  • Blog 16752
  • Blog 22097
  • Blog 26950
  • Blog 29228
  • Jonathan's solar observations
  • Blog 12699
  • Blog 16759
  • Blog 22120
  • Blog 26986
  • Blog 29229
  • Planetary Geologist's Blog
  • Cosmic musings
  • Blog 12720
  • SOLAR OBSERVATION REPORTS
  • Blog 22157
  • Blog 26992
  • Blog 29232
  • harryt's Blog
  • Learn astronomy
  • Blog 12723
  • Blog 16799
  • Blog 27019
  • Blog 29236
  • perks2008's Blog
  • Activity Blog
  • Blog 12742
  • Blog 16802
  • Blog 22224
  • Blog 27021
  • Blog 29248
  • BIGFOOT's Blog
  • Blog 12744
  • Blog 16811
  • Blog 22231
  • Blog 27026
  • Blog 29249
  • BIGFOOT's Blog
  • Blog 12746
  • Blog 16841
  • Blog 22247
  • Blog 27049
  • Blog 29251
  • Ttyttt
  • New Zealand - Astro Memories
  • Blog 16843
  • Blog 22268
  • Blog 27053
  • Blog 29253
  • headphonesky's Blog
  • Blog 12757
  • Blog 16902
  • Blog 22271
  • Blog 27055
  • Blog 29255
  • nameunknown's Blog
  • Blog 12764
  • Blog 16903
  • Blog 22321
  • Blog 27059
  • Blog 29264
  • okbeautyfacial
  • Blog 12775
  • finderscope
  • Blog 22322
  • Blog 27061
  • Blog 29279
  • test's Blog
  • Blog 12776
  • Blog 16948
  • Blog 22413
  • Blog 27072
  • Blog 29280
  • jonathan's Oberving Blog
  • Blog 12787
  • Blog 16950
  • Blog 22419
  • Blog 27073
  • Blog 29286
  • leicestergeordie's Blog
  • Blog 12792
  • Blog 16963
  • Help required by another newbie :-/
  • Blog 27075
  • Blog 29289
  • Geryllax Vu's Blog
  • The dome has landed
  • Blog 16974
  • Blog 22490
  • Blog 27077
  • Blog 29293
  • dorothypenelope
  • Blog 12799
  • Blog 16984
  • Blog 22505
  • Blog 27080
  • Blog 29294
  • Liam Watters
  • Blog 12824
  • Blog 16988
  • Blog 22533
  • Blog 27082
  • Blog 29304
  • APPLE's Blog
  • Blog 12826
  • Blog 17025
  • Blog 22542
  • Blog 27099
  • Blog 29308
  • E3RCH's Blog
  • Blog 12828
  • Blog 17080
  • Blog 22548
  • Blog 27103
  • Blog 29310
  • Lab of Oz
  • Blog 12835
  • Blog 17104
  • Blog 22574
  • Blog 27105
  • Blog 29312
  • attewella's Blog
  • Blog 12838
  • Blog 17149
  • Nick's blog, including AOSX (Astronomy on OSX)
  • Blog 27121
  • Blog 29316
  • Spacecadet2010's Blog
  • Blog 12861
  • Blog 17154
  • Todd8137s adventure into space
  • Blog 27135
  • Blog 29332
  • inatthedeepend's Blog
  • Blog 12868
  • Blog 17157
  • Blog 22658
  • Blog 27138
  • Blog 29348
  • harrodleyla's Blog
  • Blog 12875
  • Blog 17176
  • Blog 22689
  • Blog 27139
  • Blog 29350
  • betigib's Blog
  • Blog 12890
  • Blog 17179
  • Blog 22718
  • Blog 27141
  • Blog 29352
  • Carl Sagan Videos
  • Blog 12901
  • Blog 17225
  • Wordpress Webhosting
  • Blog 27142
  • Blog 29353
  • great_bear's Blog
  • Blog 17228
  • Blog 22741
  • Blog 27180
  • Blog 29354
  • cocktail dresses
  • Blog 12934
  • Blog 17248
  • Blog 22747
  • Blog 27187
  • Blog 29355
  • Viper2000's Blog
  • Blog 12940
  • Blog 17249
  • Blog 22798
  • Blog 27208
  • Blog 29357
  • spacenut's Blog
  • Blog 12983
  • Blog 17287
  • Blog 22857
  • Blog 27217
  • Blog 29360
  • Vimax Singapore Reviews - Vimax Top Male Enhancement Pills Products
  • Blog 13013
  • Blog 17337
  • Blog 22875
  • Blog 27218
  • Blog 29365
  • alex's Blog
  • Blog 13020
  • Blog 17394
  • Blog 22894
  • Blog 27219
  • Blog 29368
  • supriyaatco's Blog
  • Blog 13026
  • Blog 17398
  • Blog 22970
  • Blog 27223
  • Blog 29369
  • ChrisMseeker's Blog
  • Blog 13061
  • Blog 17490
  • Blog 22971
  • Blog 27224
  • Blog 29382
  • mytelescope's Blog
  • Blog 13080
  • View From Neath
  • Blog 23056
  • Blog 27227
  • Blog 29385
  • mytelescope's Blog
  • Blog 13086
  • Blog 17501
  • Blog 23057
  • Blog 27228
  • Blog 29387
  • what atlas should you get with a 8" dob
  • Blog 13102
  • Blog 17534
  • Blog 23105
  • Blog 27229
  • Blog 29389
  • DIY Pier Project
  • Blog 13103
  • Blog 17536
  • Blog 23122
  • Blog 27252
  • Blog 29392
  • William32's Blog
  • Blog 13107
  • Blog 17545
  • Blog 27275
  • Blog 29395
  • collamition
  • Blog 13113
  • Blog 17560
  • Blog 23154
  • Blog 27278
  • Blog 29398
  • what atlas
  • Blog 13131
  • Blog 17562
  • Blog 23187
  • Blog 27279
  • Blog 29408
  • Round Midnight
  • Blog 13143
  • Blog 17577
  • Blog 23188
  • Blog 27282
  • Blog 29410
  • Steve H's Blog
  • Blog 13176
  • Blog 17580
  • Blog 23195
  • Blog 27284
  • Blog 29412
  • iristrista's Blog
  • Blog 13213
  • Blog 17592
  • Blog 23255
  • Blog 27308
  • Blog 29414
  • iristrista's Blog
  • Blog 13224
  • Blog 17621
  • Blog 23273
  • Blog 27332
  • Blog 29460
  • Gottzi's Blog
  • Blog 13227
  • Blog 17622
  • Blog 23282
  • Blog 27362
  • Blog 29529
  • africankitty's Blog
  • Blog 13252
  • Blog 17627
  • Blog 23329
  • Blog 27370
  • Blog 29563
  • todd8137's Blog
  • Blog 13262
  • Blog 17648
  • Blog 23359
  • Blog 27371
  • Blog 29565
  • Moon man show me your feet
  • Blog 13295
  • Blog 17661
  • Blog 23368
  • Blog 27372
  • Blog 29566
  • Spikey's Blog
  • Blog 13315
  • Blog 17668
  • Blog 23390
  • Blog 27376
  • Blog 29622
  • Steve H's Blog
  • Blog 13324
  • Blog 17683
  • Blog 23405
  • Blog 27377
  • Blog 29651
  • Astronome's Blog
  • Blog 13360
  • Blog 17693
  • Blog 23449
  • Blog 27379
  • Blog 29658
  • crashtestdummy's Blog
  • Blog 13370
  • Blog 17722
  • Blog 23474
  • Blog 27382
  • Blog 29684
  • Sussex Dark Sites
  • Blog 13374
  • Blog 17772
  • Blog 23479
  • Blog 27402
  • Blog 29768
  • My Astrophotography Journey
  • Blog 13376
  • Blog 17776
  • Blog 23491
  • Blog 27403
  • Blog 29771
  • LodestarLive Development
  • Blog 13377
  • Blog 17777
  • Blog 23494
  • Blog 27421
  • Blog 29775
  • Koraki's Blog
  • Blog 13380
  • Blog 17783
  • Blog 23500
  • Blog 27422
  • Blog 29795
  • redgreen1's Blog
  • Blog 13411
  • Blog 17793
  • Blog 23638
  • Blog 27427
  • Blog 29810
  • The Stars Are My Pills
  • Blog 13420
  • Inane ramblings of baldy bain
  • Blog 23649
  • Blog 27428
  • Blog 29822
  • Blog 13422
  • Blog 17842
  • Collimation Craziness!!
  • Blog 27440
  • Blog 29849
  • Johnny4365's Blog
  • Blog 13428
  • Blog 17871
  • Blog 23673
  • Blog 27442
  • Blog 29868
  • stargazer benjji's Blog
  • Buzz buzz buzz !!
  • Blog 17876
  • Blog 23687
  • Blog 27443
  • Blog 29940
  • BexSmyth's Blog
  • Blog 13439
  • Blog 23700
  • Blog 27445
  • Blog 30042
  • whitestar83's Blog
  • Blog 13481
  • Blog 17920
  • Blog 23707
  • Blog 27446
  • Blog 30043
  • GrahamTutt's Blog
  • Blog 13503
  • Blog 17938
  • Blog 23722
  • Blog 27450
  • Blog 30055
  • mart1983's Blog
  • Blog 13509
  • Blog 17949
  • Blog 23747
  • Blog 27480
  • Blog 30099
  • Moox's Blog
  • Blog 13563
  • Blog 17987
  • Blog 23768
  • Blog 27488
  • Blog 30100
  • Jimmy Zhu's Blog
  • Blog 13565
  • Blog 18019
  • Blog 23856
  • Blog 27495
  • Blog 30129
  • Weezy's Blog
  • Blog 13605
  • Blog 18020
  • Blog 23935
  • Blog 27500
  • Blog 30318
  • darry lwall's Blog
  • East Midlands Stargazers
  • Blog 18033
  • Blog 23996
  • Blog 27502
  • Blog 30332
  • Celestial adventures
  • Blog 13675
  • Blog 18061
  • Blog 24038
  • Blog 27505
  • Blog 30403
  • stash_old's Blog
  • Blog 13701
  • Blog 18100
  • Blog 24057
  • Blog 27510
  • Blog 30479
  • My info i dont want to lose
  • Blog 13707
  • Blog 18179
  • Blog 24087
  • Blog 27513
  • Blog 30482
  • Psychobilly's Blog
  • Blog 13732
  • Blog 18181
  • Blog 24104
  • Blog 27521
  • Blog 30506
  • frosty's Blog
  • Blog 13733
  • Blog 18203
  • Blog 24157
  • Blog 27529
  • Blog 30595
  • TFRM's Blog
  • Blog 13741
  • Blog 18222
  • Blog 24198
  • Blog 27545
  • Blog 30617
  • daiwelly's Blog
  • Blog 13749
  • Blog 18236
  • Blog 24213
  • Blog 27559
  • Blog 30618
  • framos41's Blog
  • Blog 13764
  • Blog 18242
  • Blog 24231
  • Blog 27560
  • Blog 30629
  • kjh's Blog
  • Blog 13776
  • Blog 18243
  • Blog 24240
  • Blog 27561
  • Blog 30738
  • dezmo1's Blog
  • Blog 13808
  • Blog 18274
  • Blog 24250
  • Blog 27562
  • Blog 30782
  • PaulCH's Blog
  • Blog 13836
  • Blog 18287
  • Blog 24251
  • Blog 27563
  • Blog 30787
  • Andy's Column
  • Blog 13875
  • Blog 18291
  • Blog 24335
  • Blog 27565
  • Blog 30788
  • DommyDevil18's Blog
  • Blog 13880
  • Blog 18303
  • Blog 24339
  • Blog 27566
  • Blog 30795
  • sidewind's Blog
  • Blog 13884
  • Blog 18313
  • Blog 24394
  • Blog 27567
  • Blog 30812
  • O2B3's Blog
  • Blog 13890
  • Blog 18316
  • Blog 24420
  • Blog 27569
  • Blog 30819
  • Cassiopeia's cat
  • Blog 13907
  • Blog 18364
  • Blog 24483
  • Blog 27579
  • Blog 30929
  • 9988idc's Blog
  • Blog 13953
  • Blog 18369
  • Blog 24515
  • Blog 27586
  • Blog 30958
  • jimmmy's Blog
  • Blog 13959
  • Blog 18384
  • Blog 24533
  • Blog 27593
  • Blog 31027
  • vracelysarux's Blog
  • Blog 13993
  • Blog 18387
  • Blog 24540
  • Blog 27594
  • Blog 31030
  • Compositeman's Blog
  • Blog 14003
  • What have I seen.....
  • Blog 24560
  • Blog 27595
  • Blog 31032
  • Saganite's Blog
  • Blog 14031
  • Blog 18434
  • Blog 24566
  • Blog 27610
  • Blog 31033
  • Saganite's Blog
  • Blog 14037
  • Blog 18444
  • Blog 24582
  • Blog 27611
  • Blog 31037
  • My program in JavaScript related to stars
  • Blog 14099
  • Blog 18533
  • Blog 24603
  • Blog 27613
  • Blog 31039
  • Rogue1892's Blog
  • Blog 14100
  • Blog 18554
  • Blog 24615
  • Blog 27614
  • Blog 31055
  • Langy's Blog
  • Blog 14118
  • Blog 18565
  • Blog 24624
  • Blog 27615
  • Blog 31058
  • dennis65's Blog
  • Blog 14127
  • Blog 18569
  • Blog 24626
  • Blog 27624
  • Blog 31062
  • A Beginers Diary
  • Blog 14132
  • Blog 18573
  • Blog 24627
  • Blog 27633
  • Blog 31135
  • Gary170782's Blog
  • Blog 14160
  • Blog 18581
  • Blog 24637
  • Blog 27637
  • Blog 31260
  • cnapton1981's Blog
  • Blog 14196
  • Blog 18597
  • Blog 24658
  • Blog 27667
  • Blog 31296
  • chocoholicJ's Blog
  • First Contact
  • Blog 18620
  • Blog 24669
  • Blog 27669
  • Blog 31540
  • Blogstronomy
  • Blog 14274
  • Blog 18652
  • Blog 24685
  • Blog 27671
  • Blog 31580
  • SarasotaSean's Blog
  • Blog 14336
  • Blog 18669
  • Blog 24686
  • Blog 27672
  • Blog 31626
  • bestecig's Blog
  • Blog 14350
  • Blog 18679
  • Blog 24696
  • Blog 27673
  • Blog 31781
  • idigitize's Blog
  • Blog 14394
  • Blog 18683
  • Blog 24712
  • Blog 27680
  • Blog 31865
  • jelrichardson's Blog
  • Blog 14400
  • Blog 18691
  • Blog 24718
  • Blog 27686
  • Blog 31875
  • Hoppity's Blog
  • Blog 14401
  • Blog 18715
  • Blog 24748
  • Blog 27688
  • Blog 31876
  • GreatAttractor's Software
  • Blog 14403
  • Blog 18742
  • Blog 24749
  • Blog 27691
  • Blog 31910
  • Tandem master's Blog
  • Blog 14410
  • Blog 18754
  • Blog 24783
  • Blog 27692
  • Blog 32021
  • Evie's info
  • Blog 14418
  • Blog 18774
  • Blog 24844
  • Blog 27695
  • Blog 32085
  • big john 2's Blog
  • Blog 14430
  • Blog 18783
  • Blog 24895
  • Blog 27701
  • Blog 32119
  • cutepetgroomer's Blog
  • Blog 14433
  • Blog 18800
  • Blog 24916
  • Blog 27713
  • Blog 32147
  • Back Yard Observations
  • Blog 14440
  • Blog 18817
  • Blog 24926
  • Blog 27714
  • Blog 32174
  • nicoleanderson's Blog
  • Blog 14473
  • Blog 18819
  • Blog 24947
  • Blog 27716
  • Blog 32243
  • kerrylewis' Blog
  • Blog 14488
  • Blog 18846
  • Blog 24949
  • Blog 27717
  • Blog 32266
  • Confusion
  • Blog 14491
  • Blog 18858
  • Blog 24950
  • Blog 27718
  • Blog 32289
  • prabal's Astronmy log
  • Blog 14509
  • Blog 18933
  • Blog 24957
  • Blog 27721
  • Blog 32336
  • aicellrisf's Blog
  • Blog 14522
  • Blog 18942
  • Blog 24959
  • Blog 27737
  • Blog 32340
  • Lightridges-new version
  • Blog 14529
  • Which end do I look into?
  • ISS Pass
  • Blog 27745
  • Blog 32501
  • Lightbridges-any problems with the new versions?
  • Blog 14535
  • Blog 19052
  • Blog 24975
  • Blog 27749
  • Blog 32696
  • shlljhn's Blog
  • Blog 14569
  • Blog 19055
  • Blog 24979
  • Blog 27751
  • Blog 32843
  • pojara's Blog
  • Blog 14590
  • Blog 19064
  • tibbs1972archive
  • Blog 27752
  • Blog 32883
  • subrata's Blog
  • Blog 14616
  • Blog 19065
  • Blog 25006
  • Blog 27758
  • Blog 32927
  • Stream of Bewilderment
  • Blog 14636
  • Blog 19076
  • Blog 25057
  • Blog 27764
  • Blog 33051
  • 4 Stellar Shows This Week
  • Blog 14647
  • Blog 19082
  • Blog 25061
  • Blog 27788
  • Blog 33104
  • Adamzy's Blog
  • Blog 14654
  • Blog 19083
  • Blog 25065
  • Blog 27795
  • Blog 33147
  • mikeporter's Blog
  • Blog 14672
  • Blog 19101
  • Blog 25077
  • Blog 27835
  • Blog 33175
  • veberlylur's Blog
  • Blog 14708
  • Llama in Space
  • Blog 25079
  • Blog 27869
  • Blog 33239
  • greyhaven's Blog
  • Onwards to Mars, onwards to Mars!
  • Blog 19121
  • Blog 25087
  • Blog 27880
  • Blog 33298
  • Explosions in the Sky
  • Blog 14765
  • Blog 19127
  • Blog 25118
  • Blog 27891
  • Blog 33456
  • kerrylewis' Blog
  • Blog 14790
  • Blog 19131
  • Blog 25119
  • Blog 27930
  • Mike's random stuff blog..
  • Jupiters moons
  • Blog 14838
  • Blog 19147
  • Blog 25136
  • Blog 27934
  • Blog 33529
  • A 'StarGazers' Journey
  • Blog 14840
  • Blog 19159
  • Blog 25176
  • Blog 27938
  • Blog 33610
  • Andrew W's Blog
  • Blog 14845
  • Blog 19171
  • Blog 25202
  • Blog 28008
  • Blog 33879
  • American flyer's Blog
  • Blog 14853
  • Blog 19175
  • Blog 25204
  • Blog 28033
  • Qualia's Blog
  • Jobie's Blog
  • Blog 14854
  • Yet Another Blog
  • Blog 25255
  • Blog 28044
  • Blog 34130
  • andyin2014's Blog
  • Blog 14864
  • Blog 19205
  • Blog 25324
  • Blog 28059
  • Blog 34179
  • Blog 14871
  • Blog 19232
  • Blog 25369
  • Blog 28072
  • Blog 34208
  • meng82's Blog
  • Blog 14888
  • Blog 19264
  • Blog 25373
  • Blog 28150
  • Blog 34209
  • Blog 14893
  • Feeling Through the Darkness
  • Blog 25392
  • Blog 28167
  • Blog 34324
  • chellycowdy's Blog
  • Blog 14922
  • Blog 19270
  • Blog 25394
  • Blog 28168
  • Blog 34348
  • MikeSandersBlog.com
  • Blog 14933
  • Blog 19295
  • Blog 25430
  • Blog 28200
  • Blog 34351
  • Faye's blog
  • Blog 14948
  • Blog 19315
  • Blog 25437
  • Blog 28231
  • Blog 34384
  • dyhan316's Blog
  • Blog 14962
  • Blog 19337
  • Blog 25440
  • Blog 28252
  • Blog 34436
  • mickmurphy's Blog
  • To blog or not to blog that is the question
  • Blog 19346
  • Blog 25456
  • Blog 28261
  • Blog 34474
  • Joey's Blog
  • Blog 14997
  • Blog 19359
  • Blog 25465
  • Blog 28297
  • Blog 34501
  • toftm
  • Blog 14998
  • Blog 19372
  • Blog 25478
  • Blog 28322
  • Blog 34559
  • DSLR journey
  • Blog 15002
  • Blog 19381
  • Blog 25496
  • Blog 28325
  • Blog 34571
  • Alienfox's Blog
  • Blog 15041
  • Blog 19404
  • Blog 25513
  • Blog 28349
  • Blog 34602
  • daveclarke's Blog
  • Blog 15088
  • Small refractor diaries
  • Blog 25532
  • Blog 28359
  • Blog 34663
  • wxsatuser's Blog
  • Blog 15095
  • Blog 19431
  • Blog 25573
  • Blog 28361
  • Blog 34759
  • New Guy
  • Blog 15111
  • Blog 19434
  • Blog 25646
  • Blog 28374
  • Blog 34827
  • A Rush And A Push And The Sky Is Ours or Astronomy, Here We Come
  • Blog 15112
  • Blog 19448
  • Blog 25659
  • Blog 28391
  • Blog 34931
  • Central District Astronomy
  • Blog 19514
  • Blog 25684
  • Blog 28392
  • Blog 35004
  • jefrs' Blog
  • Blog 15185
  • Blog 19538
  • Blog 25715
  • Blog 28395
  • Blog 35021
  • Jocular
  • Solaris
  • Blog 19561
  • Blog 25716
  • Blog 28407
  • Blog 35026
  • Home 2 Heaven
  • Blog 15202
  • Blog 19564
  • Blog 25724
  • Blog 28427
  • Blog 35027
  • Musings from The Fen Edge
  • Blog 15212
  • Blog 19582
  • Blog 25732
  • Blog 28442
  • Blog 35205
  • jimjam11's Blog
  • Blog 15245
  • Blog 19590
  • Blog 25792
  • Blog 28478
  • Blog 35227
  • Luke's Solar Blog
  • Blog 15252
  • Blog 19607
  • Astro Projects
  • Blog 28484
  • Blog 35305
  • Marketing News
  • Blog 15258
  • Blog 19622
  • Blog 25804
  • Blog 28485
  • Blog 35402
  • Laston-Pluto1's Blog
  • Blog 15261
  • Blog 19648
  • Blog 25805
  • Blog 28487
  • Blog 35589
  • DSLR Astrophotography
  • Blog 15315
  • Blog 19650
  • Blog 25807
  • Blog 28488
  • Blog 36067
  • Hither Green Skies
  • Blog 15333
  • Blog 19655
  • Blog 25809
  • Blog 28504
  • Blog 36108
  • Help plz
  • Blog 15346
  • Blog 19684
  • Blog 25824
  • Blog 28505
  • Blog 36236
  • kenny k's Blog
  • Blog 15349
  • Blog 19744
  • Blog 25828
  • Blog 28506
  • Blog 36242
  • kenny k's Blog
  • Blog 15353
  • Blog 19752
  • Blog 25843
  • Blog 28509
  • Blog 36244
  • IenAABQDVmk32Xq's Blog
  • Learner Blog
  • Blog 19753
  • Blog 25862
  • Blog 28510
  • Blog 36245
  • quimby44's Blog
  • Blog 15421
  • Blog 19777
  • Blog 25863
  • Blog 28511
  • Blog 36247
  • ngc6872's Blog
  • Blog 15429
  • Blog 19850
  • Blog 25864
  • Blog 28530
  • Blog 36388
  • Investigate911's Blog
  • Blog 15439
  • Blog 19851
  • Blog 25899
  • Blog 28543
  • Blog 36393
  • BiBi's Blog
  • Blog 15508
  • Blog 19875
  • Blog 25902
  • Blog 28588
  • Blog 36448
  • Bert B's Blog
  • Blog 15511
  • Blog 19932
  • Blog 25912
  • Blog 28589
  • Blog 36546
  • Toward First Light - And Beyond!
  • Blog 15534
  • Blog 19938
  • Blog 25944
  • Blog 28590
  • Blog 36693
  • ToTo123's Blog
  • Blog 15564
  • Just Looking platform project
  • Blog 26014
  • Blog 28619
  • Blog 36718
  • ToTo123's Blog
  • Blog 15569
  • Blog 19999
  • Blog 26042
  • Blog 28632
  • Photosbykev's Blog
  • ToTo123's Blog
  • Blog 15654
  • Blog 20028
  • Blog 26058
  • Blog 28633
  • An Ample Astronomer....
  • The Western Veil Nebula WIP report
  • Blog 15667
  • Blog 20042
  • Blog 26077
  • Blog 28685
  • My test blog
  • Phil42's Blog
  • Blog 15702
  • Blog 20068
  • Blog 26088
  • Blog 28700
  • mr saddo's Blog
  • photopete's Blog
  • Blog 15714
  • Blog 20072
  • Blog 26092
  • VigRX Plus Reviews
  • mr saddo's Blog
  • C31045's Blog
  • Blog 15748
  • Blog 20085
  • Blog 26098
  • Blog 28722
  • Qualia's Blog
  • TraderBoo's Blog
  • Blog 15750
  • Blog 20121
  • Blog 26099
  • Blog 28723
  • The Sailor's Blog
  • Grillo's Blog
  • Blog 15767
  • Blog 20177
  • Blog 26113
  • Blog 28727
  • SGL - how to do stuff.
  • Stub Mandrel's Blog
  • Blog 15792
  • Blog 20204
  • Blog 26132
  • Blog 28730
  • James4's Blog
  • goose35's Blog
  • Blog 15835
  • Blog 20207
  • Blog 26134
  • Blog 28732
  • Polar Bear's Blog
  • ramric's Blog
  • Blog 15842
  • Blog 20229
  • Blog 26138
  • Blog 28740
  • dharma66's Blog
  • ramric's Blog
  • Blog 15876
  • Blog 20251
  • Blog 26156
  • Blog 28770
  • wfyxkfu's Blog
  • GuyR's Blog
  • Blog 15882
  • Blog 20257
  • Blog 26175
  • Blog 28797
  • skywatcher250's 1st light
  • My Nexstar adventures
  • Blog 15917
  • Blog 20289
  • Blog 26194
  • Blog 28810
  • peternb63's Blog
  • goose35's Blog
  • Blog 15936
  • Blog 20314
  • Blog 26199
  • Blog 28830
  • eriksampson24's Blog
  • Parsec's Blog
  • Blog 15955
  • Blog 20327
  • Blog 26235
  • Blog 28844
  • tibbs1972's Blog
  • alan4908's Blog
  • Blog 15956
  • Blog 20343
  • Blog 26238
  • Blog 28865
  • ksmera's Blog
  • Orkney Observatory
  • Blog 15962
  • Blog 20344
  • Blog 26246
  • Blog 28871
  • ksmera's Blog
  • Blog of the beginner
  • Blog 15963
  • Blog 20354
  • Blog 26263
  • Blog 28879
  • vimaxpills' Blog
  • JohnSadlerAstro's Blog
  • Blog 15969
  • Blog 20393
  • Blog 26274
  • Blog 28887
  • gliderpilot's Blog
  • johnisabelle's Blog
  • Blog 15997
  • Blog 20410
  • Blog 26297
  • Blog 28888
  • june's Blog
  • Rastaman88's Blog
  • Blog 16005
  • Blog 20452
  • Blog 26349
  • Blog 28893
  • coatch's Blog
  • Rastaman88's Blog
  • Blog 16016
  • Blog 20464
  • Blog 26354
  • Blog 28916
  • ASTROSTUART's Blog
  • aeajr's Blog
  • Blog 16017
  • Steve's Blog
  • Blog 26386
  • Blog 28920
  • cruizin's Blog
  • auspom's Blog
  • Blog 16040
  • Blog 20530
  • Blog 26422
  • Blog 28932
  • Astro Fascination
  • Skipper Billy's Blog
  • Blog 16060
  • Blog 20539
  • Blog 26424
  • Blog 28939
  • timsmith's Blog
  • BritAngler's Blog
  • Blog 16076
  • Blog 20563
  • Slim Weight Patch Benefits Review
  • Blog 28941
  • Astralstroll's Blog
  • The Awesome Beginners Guide to Astronomy
  • Blog 16096
  • Blog 20568
  • Blog 26448
  • Blog 28949
  • Normanski's Blog
  • The up-to-date guide on stargazing with electronics
  • Blog 16099
  • Blog 20603
  • Blog 26453
  • Blog 28950
  • Online Shopping - Radio Controlled Helicopters and Radio Controlled Cars
  • A Guide to Astronomy- a Personal View
  • Blog 16115
  • Blog 20615
  • Blog 26463
  • Blog 28960
  • DrRobin's Blog
  • MountainSkies Blog
  • Blog 16116
  • Blog 20628
  • Blog 26475
  • Blog 28971
  • lvs' Blog
  • Audi Quatro
  • Blog 16119
  • Blog 20652
  • Muscle Gain Truth Scam Program Review
  • Blog 28983
  • Daniel-K's Blog
  • Chris Cartledge
  • Blog 16125
  • Blog 20701
  • Blog 26497
  • Blog 28988
  • nickdud's Blog
  • Nigel t
  • Blog 16134
  • Blog 20745
  • Blog 26503
  • Blog 29036
  • nathanj89's Blog
  • Kainushi
  • Blog 16137
  • Blog 20814
  • Blog 26517
  • Blog 29041
  • Joseki's Blog
  • Surox's astronomy blog
  • Blog 16142
  • Blog 20851
  • Blog 26529
  • Blog 29042
  • michael001's Blog
  • HridaySabz's blog
  • Blog 16160
  • Blog 20901
  • Blog 26534
  • Blog 29053
  • jacob02's Blog
  • one more blog
  • Blog 16166
  • Blog 20945
  • Blog 26539
  • Blog 29064
  • jacob02's Blog
  • A space enthusiast
  • Blog 16215
  • Blog 20967
  • Fat Loss 4 Idiots Diet eBook Review
  • Blog 29066
  • Lee03's Blog
  • Chris's Backyard Astronomy
  • Blog 16237
  • Blog 20976
  • Fat Loss 4 Idiots Scam Diet Plan Review
  • Blog 29067
  • Marin04's Blog
  • Largest Stars in the Universe
  • Blog 16241
  • Blog 20988
  • newbie trying to take photos
  • Blog 29068
  • purerocket's Blog
  • Largest Stars in the Universe
  • Blog 16249
  • Blog 20994
  • Blog 26554
  • Blog 29069
  • mrstrellis' Blog
  • Jim
  • Blog 16264
  • Blog 21022
  • Blog 26556
  • Blog 29073
  • mrstrellis' Blog
  • Getting started with an EQ mount from the perspective of an Alt/Az imager
  • Blog 16281
  • Blog 21030
  • Blog 26561
  • Blog 29075
  • Andrew's Astronomy Blog
  • "We are made of star stuff..."
  • Blog 16297
  • Blog 21037
  • Blog 26570
  • Blog 29078
  • cobbyr6's Blog
  • Diary of an AstroNat
  • Blog 16298
  • Blog 21042
  • Blog 26577
  • Blog 29080
  • cobbyr6's Blog
  • Blog 16301
  • Blog 21052
  • Blog 26581
  • Blog 29083
  • patriots star's Blog
  • Gina
  • Blog 16315
  • Blog 21086
  • Blog 26583
  • Blog 29084
  • Steve's Blog
  • A Range of DIY 3D Printers
  • Blog 16354
  • Blog 21118
  • Blog 26596
  • Blog 29085
  • Jonathan's Moore Marathon
  • Clocks made with 3D Printed Parts
  • Blog 16370
  • Blog 21148
  • Blog 26672
  • Blog 29087
  • ollie52's Blog
  • Astrophotography Scrapbook #1
  • Blog 16395
  • Blog 21188
  • 31 Day Fat Loss Cure
  • Blog 29093
  • DIY Build - 8.5" reflector
  • The Sculptor Galaxy - NGC 253
  • Blog 16402
  • Blog 21197
  • Blog 26680
  • Blog 29097
  • Miscellaneous Personal Projects
  • Blog 16403
  • Blog 21216
  • Blog 26700
  • Blog 29098
  • ian_d's Blog
  • The Apprentice Astronomer
  • Blog 16410
  • Blog 21238
  • Blog 26710
  • Blog 29099
  • TonyD's Blog
  • Nikon D7500 DSLR for Astrophotography
  • Blog 16416
  • Blog 21254
  • Blog 26711
  • Blog 29100
  • foundaplanet's Blog
  • My Astronomy Activities
  • Blog 16419
  • Blog 21289
  • Blog 26712
  • Blog 29105
  • Planetary Geology
  • Blog 16421
  • Blog 21329
  • Blog 26715
  • Blog 29107
  • melsky's Blog
  • Improving An Aluminium tripod
  • Blog 16430
  • Blog 21391
  • Blog 26744
  • Blog 29108
  • DanielleBishell's Blog
  • Improving An Aluminium tripod
  • Blog 16436
  • Blog 21419
  • Blog 26770
  • Blog 29112
  • A Newbie Returning To The Game
  • Looking Back
  • Blog 16437
  • Blog 21433
  • Blog 26773
  • Blog 29115
  • Robstargazer15's Blog
  • Diary of a beginner
  • Blog 16454
  • Blog 21454
  • Blog 26780
  • Blog 29116
  • Astro Mods and Upgrades
  • My Journey
  • Blog 16459
  • Blog 21493
  • Blog 26790
  • Blog 29117
  • perks2008's Blog
  • Astronomy notes
  • Blog 16471
  • Blog 21498
  • Blog 26792
  • Blog 29119
  • Alf Fraser's Blog
  • Designing and Creating a New Garden with Water Feature
  • Blog 16472
  • Blog 21509
  • Blog 26793
  • Blog 29123
  • Beginner Astronomer's Blog
  • Designing and Creating a New Garden with Water Feature
  • Blog 16491
  • Blog 21515
  • Blog 26794
  • Blog 29126
  • Beginner Astronomer's Blog
  • Designing and Creating a New Garden with Water Feature
  • Blog 16526
  • Blog 21518
  • Blog 26809
  • Blog 29127
  • Mike's Lunar sketches
  • Testing blog creation
  • Blog 16559
  • Blog 21601
  • Blog 26812
  • Blog 29135
  • Avionna's Blog
  • Newbie - 8" Dob
  • Dorset Stargazers's Blog

Find results in...

Find results that contain...


Date Created

  • Start

    End


Last Updated

  • Start

    End


Filter by number of...

Joined

  • Start

    End


Group


AIM


MSN


Website URL


ICQ


Yahoo


Jabber


Skype


Interests


Location

Found 1 result

  1. Reverse-Engineering the Skymax 180 What follows should be of interest to anyone who wants to know any of the following 3 things about this scope. 1. What it looks like inside, its design, how it works, and how to dismantle it and re-assemble it safely (yes I’ve seen that video of someone disastrously taking apart a Skymax 150!). 2. Its real dimensions, including all the major components of the scope including internal mirror separation/s; 3. Its “key numbers” such as effective focal length for various amounts of back-focus or mirror separation, to allow more confident estimation of magnification, fields of view, exit pupil sizes for various configurations. When I went to try to find these details, I couldn’t find anything reliable online. It started by me noticing that the Moon, always very close to 30 arcminutes across, was filling more of the field of view than the official spec of the scope suggested it should. The scope’s advertised focal length is 2700mm, but it seemed that in the set-up I was using it was behaving more like a 3000mm. That set-up was an external Baader Diamond Steeltrak, adding quite a lot to the back-focus compared to the supplied visual back. I did a little searching around, and quickly came across the formula for the effective focal length of a catadioptric: namely EFL = f1.f2/(f1-f2-s) where “s” is the separation between the mirrors. Seeing as the focus-mechanism relies specifically on changing this separation, I had all the excuse I needed to do something I’ve come to enjoy doing: survey the scope and/or take it apart to see how it works. At the same time I also did a focuser-axis-vs-primary-optical-axis test, and discovered that the two axes differed by around 8 arc-minutes; enough to investigate trying to fix it. As it turned out, this was not a problem, it was a design feature (more later)! Anyway, to investigate, I was going to have to see how the primary mirror was affixed to the central tubes and how if at all it might be adjusted, and to do that I was definitely going to have to take the scope apart. Unfortunately as stated I couldn’t find anything online either about how properly to take it apart, in particular the mirror, focusing and collimating end; and neither could I find anything I trusted about its various dimensions. I did find one article whose author calculated back-focus and EFL relationships for a Skymax 180 of almost identical age to mine, and who even went as far as to run its dimensions such as he had them (including corrector-plate refractive index!) through a ray-tracing program; but many of the dimension inputs he used I think must have been assumed or guessed: when I measured and re-measured them I found them very different from his. And the formulae are extremely sensitive to those dimensions being accurate. Disassembly, Adjustments and How It Works The rear assembly comes apart into 2-3 main pieces: the main rear cell, i.e. the cast-metal “back end lump” of the scope you can see from the outside, out of the back of which is poking the focus knob and the visual back; and the inner mechanism comprising the 2 nested baffle tubes, the primary mirror, the focus-mechanism and the collimation-plate. The primary mirror, outer baffle tube and the focus-rod receiving plate are all effectively one bonded-together piece. Although the mirror sits against a flange in the outer baffle tube, it’s heavily bonded on so trying to address any baffle-tube orientation problems is nigh impossible. The inner baffle tube, which sits inside the outer one, becomes at its bottom a stamped flat-metal plate with three threaded holes and a cut-out recess to allow the focusing-rod through. The three holes correspond to the main collimation bolts at the back of the scope, and they are the only things supporting the primary mirror assembly inside the OTA. In other words, those 3 collimation bolts hold the entire mirror and baffle-tube assembly inside the OTA space, and adjusting them points it around inside the OTA. What this means is that the visual back on the OTA IS NOT DIRECTLY CONNECTED TO THE BAFFLE TUBE. There is a gap, and potentially an axis-kink. See my drawing, comparing the Skymax to my Intes M603: What it also means is that blindly removing those 3 collimation bolts as a first step will cause the mirror assembly and baffle tubes to, at best, hang off the focus-rod inside, and at worst, if you’ve already removed the focus receiving bearing from the rear cell, the whole baffle and mirror will be set free to collapse onto the corrector plate and secondary! Therefore: if you really wish to dis-assemble, follow my instructions below! This arrangement is interesting. In my Intes, the visual back is part of the baffle tube which extends all the way through the rear cell: eyepieces, diagonals and cameras attach directly to the baffle tube. In the Skymax here, the visual back is part of the rear housing of the OTA, only attached to the baffle tube in a subsidiary fashion via the collimation bolts, and the whole “viewing tunnel” is effectively kinked at the rear of the scope. So collimation on the Skymax is mostly getting the baffle tube to line up with the visual back and eyepiece axis. That certainly helped explain why my eyepiece axis and mirror axes were “out” when I measured them. But if there’s misalignment of the corrector plate, or if the secondary mirror-spot is out of place, then I guess there’s little you can do about it. The native focus mechanism is very simple, far simpler than that of the Intes. It comprises a threaded rod held at one end by a bearing in the main scope back cell, and at the other end attached to a rigid metal plate bonded behind the primary mirror. Turning the knob causes the plate (and hence the mirror and outer baffle tube) to move up and down the tube at a rate of about 0.8mm per knob-turn. Obviously, there must be a tiny amount of clearance between the two tubes, and it’s this clearance that causes the dreaded “mirror slop” when the focus knob is engaged. Next came the front cell which contains the 18-19mm thick corrector lens, and appears to have coatings (green and pink reflections each evident). On the inside surface of the corrector lens is the secondary mirror, an aluminized spot surrounded by a cup-shaped black plastic baffle skirt. This skirt is glued to the secondary mirror, but in my case NOT CENTRALLY! I removed it, thinking in the process that I was reducing the Central Obstruction as well, but soon realised that because the primary mirror hole and retaining-ring were themselves much wider than the widest part of the secondary baffle-skirt, there was no point. Nonetheless having removed it, I cleaned off the residue, re-centred and re-attached it. With the baffle-skirt in place, the remaining exposed secondary mirror is 36.5mm diameter. The main tube itself was a loose fit: larger than the fitting-flange on the front cell, and smaller than the flange on the rear cell in each case by more than I was entirely happy with (it fits inside the lip of the rear cell and outside at the front cell). As such, the tube had to deform in each case slightly when doing up the 4 retaining screws at each end. I plan at some stage to get a carbon tube with a better fit. The dovetail is bolted to the tube, not to the much-more-solid cells, and the tube is only held on to the chunky front and rear cells by those 4 screws each end. Rings for this scope would be a good addition, or a longer dovetail to attach directly to the main cells. What follows is a step-by-step guide to dis-assembling the scope. It describes taking everything apart except the components of the front cell and the corrector plate. Before you start, one very important thing is worth mentioning. As the pictures above show, the baffle-tube arrangement comprises two tubes, an inner one and an outer one. The primary mirror is bonded to the outer one. The outer one is free to slide up and down the inner tube (there is lubrication between them). The main thing which fixes the position of the outer tube, and prevents it from sliding anywhere it likes, is a threaded rod attached to a bulkhead behind the primary, the other end of which pokes through the back of the OTA. The outer tube is held in place by the focus knob, which when turned, activates the thread and moves the outer baffle-tube, and hence the primary mirror, up and down the inner one. Here’s the important bit: if you remove that focus knob, and the OTA is sitting “corrector down” (as instructed in the step 6-8 below) step 8 has you seemingly removing the only thing preventing the outer tube from sliding all the way down, off the inner tube, and onto the corrector plate inside. There is one design feature designed to prevent that from happening: a rubber O-ring sat in a groove towards the end of the inner baffle tube, designed to stop the outer tube from moving any further. BEFORE YOU START, CHECK THAT THAT O-RING IS STILL THERE. Rubber does perish eventually, and if you cannot see that O-ring, I leave it up to you to think of a different way to remove the focus knob to prevent the mishap. Step by Step Dismantling 1. Attach a visual back that extends beyond the focus knob. You’ll be using it to place/balance the rear assembly vertically on a flat surface later. 2. Remove rubber focus knob (it simply pulls straight off). 3. Rotate the protruding brass cylinder clockwise, to gradually expose the threaded rod. 4. Unscrew and set aside the small central Philips screw (and possibly small washer) at the top of the threaded rod (it may be a C-clip instead, in which case remove that). 5. Remove main telescope front plastic “lens cap”. 6. Place scope “front down” on a level surface. 7. Partially, maybe ½ a turn, unscrew the three main (bigger) collimation bolts at the back. BUT ONLY UNTIL THEY LOSE THEIR TIGHTNESS – DO NOT COMPLETELY UNSCREW THEM YET! THE MIRROR IS ESSENTIALLY HANGING OFF THESE SCREWS INSIDE THE OTA! Do not touch the smaller recessed “locking screws” – keeping them in place allows you to restore the position of the primary at roughly the same orientation when it comes to re-assembly. 8. Unscrew the 3 screws on the flange around the focus-knob, and set them and the flange-plate aside. 9. Unscrew, by hand, and set aside the exposed brass focusing assembly (ACW) all the way off (perhaps 20+ turns!). Also notice and remove a black rubber washer underneath the assembly. Be careful of the evil black grease! 10. The threaded rod, covered in black grease, will now be poking up through the hole in the back plate. 11. Unscrew and set aside the 4 screws on the side of the OTA holding the rear cell to the main OTA around its outside. From here you need to be very careful with your movements to avoid things getting knocked and toppling over. 12. Lift the whole rear assembly out of the main tube and carefully place it on the level surface “focuser down” (i.e. collimation screws and visual back at the bottom). 13. With a small/short hex socket-insert, with your fingers from underneath, carefully unscrew/twiddle off all the way the 3 main collimation bolts that you loosened earlier. Once done, the primary mirror assembly and baffle tubes are now only resting on the OTA’s rear cell. 14. Whilst supporting the rear cell on your flat surface, and holding the baffle tube, gently lift the baffle tube (and primary mirror and focus-rod) away from the main rear cell. Be careful not to lose 3 hidden fat little washers between the plate at the bottom of the baffle-tube and the rear cell: they can stick to the underside of the plate and fall off later if you don’t pay notice them. 15. Remove the O ring around and near the top of the inner baffle tube. This O ring prevents the outer tube from sliding all the way off if somehow the focus-rod isn’t holding it. It’s tricky to remove with all the grease lubricating the two tubes: try not to damage it. 16. You can now separate the two tubes by pulling the outer tube off the inner: the outer tube with its mirror, focus-plate and (evil-black-greased) focus rod; and the inner, with its flat plate at the bottom. 17. Further dis-assembly of the primary mirror and its components is not possible, as you will see that the primary mirror is extremely heavily bonded in place on its tube. Re-Assembly 1. Place the rear section on the hard surface, resting on the Visual Back 2. Place the 3 fat doughnut black rubber washers on the 3 larger collimation-holes (they act as crude tensioning-springs for the collimation-bolts) 3. Carefully place the collimation-plate/inner baffle-tube so that its 3 holes match the main collimation holes, and such that the focus-knob cut-out matches the focus-hole in the rear cell 4. From underneath, using a short suitable hex-insert, screw in the 3 main collimation bolts most of the way, but do not tighten 5. If necessary, re-grease the lower part of the baffle tube where the outer will slide over it 6. Gently and carefully lower the primary mirror / outer baffle-tube onto the inner one 7. Re-fit the rubber O-ring into its slot 8. Remove excess grease from the upper end of the baffle tubes 9. Bring the 2 halves of the scope back together again: carefully lower the rear assembly back into the main tube, and re-attach the 4 screws. The scope should now be on its front, with the visual back “up”. 10. The black-grease threaded rod should now be poking up through the focuser-hole. Replace the black flat rubber washer into that recess 11. Screw on the focuser assembly, “thicker bit” first, clockwise onto the threaded rod until it’s all the way into the recess, and a couple of turns more. 12. Screw on the small locking screw onto the end of the threaded rod (or replace the C-clip if that’s what it is) 13. Replace the flange-plate and secure it with its 3 screws 14. Push the rubber knob back on 15. Screw the (larger) collimation-bolts back until they are reasonably firm: having not touched the smaller locking-screws, this last action returns the primary mirror assembly to close to the orientation it was before you started. Dimensions and Measurements A. 45.4 mm: Front Rim to centre of Corrector Plate B. 18.6 mm: Thickness of Corrector at Centre C. 42.5 mm: Depth of Secondary Baffle Skirt D. 421.5 mm: Front Rim to Front Rim of Rear Cell E. 357.5 +- Nx0.787 mm: Secondary Mirror to Centre of Primary Mirror where N = no. full turns ACW from where supplied visual back & 2” diagonal come to focus (more back-focus => smaller separation => bigger focal length) F. 83 mm: Front of Rear Cell to Flat Back of Rear Cell (not including Visual Back attachment!) G. 37 mm: Exposed Diameter of Secondary Mirror H. 58 mm: Secondary Baffle Skirt Width (at wide end) I. 42.5 mm: Depth of Secondary Skirt J. 63 mm: Diameter of Primary Mirror Retaining Ring (i.e. wider than secondary skirt!) K. 200 mm: Primary Mirror Diameter (i.e. oversized) Other quantities not shown on diagram: F1: 472 mm: Primary Mirror Focal Length (measured as half the centre of curvature, itself measured from its reflecting a point source F2: 127.92 mm implied Secondary Mirror Focal length (to force formula to give 2700 mm with supplied back and diagonal and all other measured dimensions. Very difficult to measure). also: - 0.787 mm pitch of focus-knob (movement in primary for one full turn of native focus-knob) - 665.3 mm Circumference of lip of front cell (=> diameter 211.8 mm) - 670 mm Circumference of inside of OTA tube at front (=> diameter 213.2 mm) - 1.60 mm OTA tube thickness - 682 mm circumference of INSIDE lip of rear cell (=> diameter 217.1 mm) - 681 mm Circumference of outside of OTA tube at rear (=> diameter 216.8 mm) The way the main (steel) tube fits on to the front and rear cells is worth taking note, if you plan to fit a carbon tube, for instance. The tube slots OVER the cell at the front, but INSIDE the cell at the back. The difference between the two meeting-face diameters is 217.1mm less 211.8mm, i.e. 5.3mm. Which means that should you wish to upgrade to a, say, carbon tube, it would need to have at most 2.65mm wall-thickness. The steel thickness on this scope is 1.6mm, which is accommodated by the fact that it’s flexible, and on this scope at least needs to flex to fit. The native focus mechanism is, as shown, a knob on the back which moves the primary mirror up and down the tube. The secondary mirror is fixed in place as an aluminized spot on the back of the front corrector lens. Focusing via that knob changes the separation between the mirrors, changing the focus-point and back-focus and changing the system’s Effective Focal Length, according to the formula EFL = - f1.f2/(f1 – f2 – s), s being the mirror separation. If I could simply find out what the individual focal lengths of the two mirrors were, and what the mirror separation was for given positions of the focus knob for a given back-focus amounts, I could calculate what focal length a given arrangement engenders, and therefore construct a more accurate mag / exitpupil / FoV ready-reckoner to stick to the side of the scope. I started by roughly estimating what these numbers might be just by “eyeballing” the scope, doing some crude measuring and putting together a simple spreadsheet. I hoped that would be close enough and I wouldn’t have to dis-assemble. For instance f1, based on reflecting a point source back to itself from the mirror seemed about 450mm, f2 around 90mm and judging by where the main mirror looked positioned, the mirror separation looked something like 370mm. Then I noticed something about the EFL formula. f1 x f2 is going to be a reasonably large number, in this case 40,500. f1-f2-s is going to be quite a small number, here -10, suggesting an estimated EFL of 4050mm. Hmmm. Big number divided by small number is going to be very dependent on the small number, especially if that small number is a difference in measurements. It doesn’t take much leeway in those numbers for that denominator to be, say, 0mm for example and the calculated EFL to become infinite. Or even negative! Clearly, more precise dimensions rule here. “Rough estimates” weren’t going to cut it: I could come up with whatever results I wanted just by slightly varying the key dimensions. I was going to have to make accurate measurements. Two of these accurate measurements initially presented a challenge: the precise thickness of the corrector lens (the mirrored spot is inside the tube and at the centre of a highly curved and rather thick glass plate); and the precise position of the centre of the primary mirror (it’s recessed into the rear cell of the scope, has a big hole where its centre should be and you can’t see the thread which moves it). I needed to be ingenious about each of these. My digital micrometer saved the day. The back end of it can be used as a depth gauge, and using it I was able to accurately estimate the thickness of the corrector plate and, because the primary mirror is recessed into the rear cell, the distance below the rim of the edge of the primary (I also needed to take account of the sagitta of the primary). The distance between the front and rear cells was trivially measured from outside the fully-assembled tube. And finally, using the pitch of the threaded focusing-rod, I was able to determine the mirror separations for any position of the focus-knob. Effective Focal Length and Back-Focus All the above having been done, I was now in a position to estimate EFL for various back-focus settings, and for my various actual set-ups. These estimates are predicated on the assumption that with the supplied diagonal and Visual Back, the focal length is actually as indicated on the scope’s plaque, i.e. 2700mm. The only quantity I couldn’t easily measure, the focal length of the secondary, was the “degree of freedom” I could change that allowed me to “fix” the EFL to 2700 for a certain set-up. At some stage I’ll try to actually measure it, but this will do for now. Below is a chart showing Effective Focal Length of the Skymax180 against the likely range of back-focus behind the OTA: The geometry means that actually the EFL is a linear function of back-focus, which surprised me (see formula below). Incidentally the 440.5 is the distance from the secondary to the back of the OTA. For the Skymax 150, for example, the formulae would be the same but with a different value of “440.5” (I’ll update this post with Skymax 150 values and dimensions when I get back to London). A couple of extra data points that I didn’t include on the chart are those for the “end-stops” of the native focuser travel, i.e. 0 turns ACW and 29 turns ACW: 0 turns => -40mm backfocus (i.e. inside the rear cell!) => 1952mm EFL => 375mm mirror separation 29 turns => 1113mm backfocus => 6200mm EFL => 354mm mirror separation For those who prefer formulae to calculate these things: Effective Focal Length EFL = (BF+440.5).F1/F2 + F1 all quantities in mm; BF measured from rear of OTA Mirror separation s = F1 – F2 + F1.F2/EFL In the use of these formulae for estimating the various quantities, I’ve ignored the effect of the corrector plate. The only exception was the measurement of the Primary’s focal length, which I measured with the corrector plate removed. I don’t think it matters too much, and hopefully is partially compensated-for by my back-solving of the focal length of the Secondary to achieve 2700mm in OEM configuration. (Re-)Collimation I now had knowledge of what was mechanically going on behind the mirror and what the collimation bolts did! As mentioned, those 3 bolts are the only things attaching the primary mirror support assembly to the rest of the scope, and they basically point the mirror around the inside of the tube. The secondary is fixed, the visual back attachment is fixed, the only thing that you can change is the orientation of the primary inside the tube. Thus collimation involves aligning the primary’s axis as well as possible with the visual back’s axis and the centre of the secondary. If either of these are out of place, it’s an exercise in compromise. A popularly suggested method for aligning Maks and SCTs etc is the “hall-of-mirrors” method. But I’ve found it unsatisfactory: it can tell you if you’re reasonably close, but if you aren’t it doesn’t tell you what to adjust to get it right. I’ve found that star-test collimation is much more intuitive and sensitive. Point at something like a 2nd-mag star, ideally Polaris because it stays still, on a night of not too bad seeing. Using at least a 10mm eyepiece, and very slightly defocusing, you'll notice a set of concentric(ish) rings around a small hole with a point in the middle. Very likely though, the doughnut you see will be "squashed" towards one edge. Establish which collimation bolt best corresponds to that squashed position, by putting your hand over one side in front of the scope and seeing where the gap appears in the view: the bolt closest to that gap, or the one opposite, is the one to move first. Adjust that collimation bolt, and the squashiness will either improve or dis-improve. One proviso: as you turn the collimation, the star will move out of view, so have your controller handy so you can keep it in view during the process, to avoid spending 10 minutes re-discovering Polaris at high magnification (been there, done that). Keep going through that process until the ring-pattern is as symmetric as you can make it. I find that it comes right quite suddenly at the end. You could go one step further to do super-fine collimation (I often don't bother) by going to super-higher magnification, getting to best focus, and "symmetricizing" the Airy disc, but to do that you need almost perfect seeing which is rare. Whereas symmetricizing the doughnut can be done on more ordinary nights and gets you very close. Once there, it should hold reasonably well for the future. People call catadioptric collimation a "dark art", and one of the reasons I think is that the various internal designs are often very different, and collimation is doing different things "inside". And they never tell you what's inside, so you are effectively adjusting something by blind trial and error hoping that whatever it is lines up. If you’ve got this far, well done! And thanks. I hope this will prove useful to anybody else with a reason to want to know how this scope and its siblings (Skymax 150, 127 etc) actually work inside. Cheers, Magnus
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue. By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.