So, I’ve been using the Samyang 135mm lens for two years for astrophotography and I’ve only now discovered this thread… just after I sold the lens. I’d been using the lens with a Nikon APS-C camera on a Star Adventurer for wide field shots at and was never very happy with the images because of pronounced corner softness. Stopping down only helped a bit with the corners.
I then acquired a ZWO ASI462MC camera (1936 x 1036 pixels, 2.9 micron pixel pitch, 5.6 x 3.2mm) and wondered if the Samyang would work well with this small sensor. I found that stars did sharpen up well when the lens was stopped down to f/5.6. However, because the sensor only has 2MP the images are essentially always viewed at or near 100% and at that magnification the stars all had unsightly red borders. So, as has also been reported by some in this thread, I feel the lens doesn’t seem to play well with pixel-peeping.
What made me sell the lens was results I got with the new Askar FMA135 triplet ED scope (135mm focal length, f/4.5, £289 from FLO). With this scope and the ASI462MC I got average FWM of 1.8 pixels (8 arcseconds), and the stars show very little colour fringing. Below is an uncropped image of the Eastern Veil nebula taken (one hour in astronomical twilight) with this system
Going back to using an APS-C DSLR: the corners were a little soft but better with the Askar scope than I’d achieved with the Samyang lens. Aberrations are visible in the corners but are fairly well controlled. FWHM across the whole image was about 2 pixels (12 arcseconds). Below is a (6 minutes, so noisy) starfield taken with this system showing first the whole image and second the Pixinsight aberration inspector image (to show the edge and corner quality).
The Askar scope only covers an APS-C image circle, and obviously can’t compete with the Samyang for light gathering capability. However, if you tend to stop down the Samyang to improve image quality, the Askar presents a good alternative. The Askar is also tiny and only weighs 280g, so is great for a travel rig.
Andy