Jump to content

sgl_imaging_challenge_banner_31.thumb.jpg.b7a41d6a0fa4e315f57ea3e240acf140.jpg

Jason D

Members
  • Content Count

    691
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Community Reputation

251 Excellent

1 Follower

About Jason D

  • Rank
    Proto Star

Profile Information

  • Gender
    Not Telling
  • Location
    California, USA

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1. I believe the issue reported by the OP could be (and I am speculating) due to the holographic optical piece mounted on its metallic casing at an angle. Referring to the OP's original photo, note how the pattern looks OK along the 2:00<->8:00 line but looks at its worse along the 11:00<->5:00 line. Jason
  2. That does not look right. I would ask for a replacement. Here is mine. Don't mind what I was trying to do in these photos -- just check the uniformity of the rings.
  3. Your collimation as shown on the above photo looks good Jason
  4. Secondary mirror silhouette will always appear skewed towards the primary mirror. It is just more paramount for fast scopes. The cross hairs in the photo are the spider vanes. These should be ignored when collimating. Refer to my photo in the pre reply. My scope's spider vanes intersect slightly to the right of the center spot.
  5. It should look like that (with an offset). Here is a photo of my collimated scope
  6. That does not mean much with respect to collimation. I would ignore that observation if I were in your shoes. Your photo does not provide enough information to evaluate your collimation. The primary center spot is not showing and the focuser edge is also not showing. A good collimation cap will have a reflective (or at leave a white) underneath surface.
  7. As the person who came up with the particular center spot shape (called Hotspot), my main target was to improve stacking the center marker reflections via Catseye XLKP autcollimator collimation tool. The tool will show several reflections of the center marker and some of these reflections will be 180 degree rotated. To stack the center marker reflection against its 180 degree rotated reflection, the radioactive symbol shape (the Hotspot) works best. Another advantage is aligning the Hotspot against the ring of the Catseye cheshire. See attachments. The Hotspot center marker is irre
  8. Based on your description, I suggest you leave the secondary mirror alone. Just ensure the primary mirror is adjusted then enjoy the views. Jason
  9. The following statement in the book "For uniform illumination of the focal plane the diagonal must be displaced away from the eyepiece and toward the primary mirror by equal amounts" is wrong!!!! Jason
  10. What you have described only checks for the primary mirror alignment which is the most critical collimation alignment -- the one responsible for coma. However, the method you have described does not evaluate the proper placement of the secondary mirror unless the secondary mirror is grossly (and I mean grossly) misaligned. Jason
  11. I presume the middle figure below matches your concern when mounting a secondary mirror without an away-from-focuser offset , am I correct? That is, as shown in the same middle figure, part of the reflected star light cone will miss the secondary mirror unless it is either properly offsetted away-from-the-focuser or the secondary mirror is large enough to intercept the whole reflected light cone, am I still correct? Well, this is a common misconception!!! If the secondary mirror is mounted with the proper away-from-focuser offset then you will get the left-hand side figure which is
  12. The slight misalignment you referenced is negligible and has no impact on your views. I would definitely ignore and not be bothered with it. Jason
  13. Hello Tim, With proper knowledge, quality laser collimators are great and accurate collimation tools. The rotational error you have described is hardly noticeable at the eyepiece for visual observation. It does not impact coma or focus but rather it has a "theoretical" impact (that is hardly noticeable visually) on the distribution of field illumination within the FOV. It should be known to any laser collimator owner that laser collimators can only used to achieve axial alignment -- when the eyepiece axis points at the primary mirror center and the primary mirror axis points at the
  14. To OP, Check this post and the next post https://stargazerslounge.com/topic/186945-collimation-woes-laser-vs-cap/?do=findComment&amp;comment=1946524 Jason
  15. Can you share the "after" photo for comparison?
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue. By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.