I use a straight forward tube with my lens, scope, and finder guider. This will allow you to adjust the length of the dew shield by sliding up and down the scope/lens should you start to see vignetting. Obviously for a scope as it is fixed focal length it's easier to determine the length of dew shield. For the lens, a bit more trial and error. If you open the lens to a short focal length then a shorter dew shield is required. Not sure if the benefits of shield would be lost at say 18mm FL My vote says try the tube first. If it doesn't work. Go down the more complicated cone route.